Group dynamics, gender and microfinance in Bolivia

Abstract

This paper examines the wider impacts, or externalities, of microfinance in Bolivia, an environment in which the loss of confidence in the formal banking system and the proactive role of the Superintendencia de Bancos in converting NGOs into deposit-taking institutions have been positive factors. Our focus is on the group-lending technology of ProMujer, which practises a 'credit plus' technology in which training, health and advisory services for women only are linked with lending (and savings services through FIE). There is some preliminary evidence that such groups have achieved the externality of stimulating collective public action outside of the immediate microfinance context (for example by lobbying for better public services or changes in policy); such growth seems to happen most readily where the group has collective experience of adversity, and|or where intragroup equality is high. They also have exemplary repayment rates, which-unlike those of most other microfinance institutions-did not fall off during the recent recession. This creates a second externality for the economy as a whole-a contribution to macro-economic stability. We hypothesise that the chain of causation goes from ProMujer's 'credit plus' ancillary services, to client loyalty to the institution, to high repayment rates, to ability to expand lending and investment. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Addiction to Microcredit: An Obstacle to Social And Financial Mobility

“…In Kenya, results from loan repayments of joint liability borrowers is reported to be well above 97 percent (Kiiru, 2007). According to Velasco and Marconi (2004), group lending provides members with the benefits of social learning, group reproduction and gender solidarity when they become a pressure group to pursue a political objective. With all of these benefits accruing to group members, loan beneficiaries are likely to stay longer than usual so as to benefit more from their groups and also more loans from the MFIs.…”

Banking on women's labour: Responsibility, risk and control in village banking in Bolivia

“…Social aspects of the intervention such as training and group membership are emphasised, despite requiring subsidy in the short‐term. The argument is made that the sense of loyalty generated among members by providing support and training is worthy of investment as it is beneficial for long‐term sustainability (Velasco and Marconi, 2004). Group membership, involvement in the administration and being seen to have responsibility for the bank may provide a platform for members to challenge gendered structures on their own terms.…”

Gender and Collective Action: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis

“…In the community forestry example in Nepal, women who recognized the poor ability of all-male patrols to effectively guard forest resources created all-women's patrols. Because of women's reliance on forest resources, they are better attuned to spot violations (Sarin 1995 (Jhabvala and Bali 1990;Velasco and Marconi 2004).…”