Abstract. Methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O) compositions in ground ice may provide information on their production mechanisms in
permafrost. However, existing gas extraction methods have not been well tested. We tested conventional wet and dry gas extraction methods using ice
wedges from Alaska and Siberia, finding that both methods can extract gas from the easily extractable parts of the ice (e.g. gas bubbles) and yield
similar results for CH4 and N2O mixing ratios. We also found insignificant effects of microbial activity during wet
extraction. However, both techniques were unable to fully extract gas from the ground ice, presumably because gas molecules adsorbed onto or enclosed
in soil aggregates are not easily extractable. Estimation of gas production in a subfreezing environment of permafrost should consider such incomplete
gas extraction.