Grammatical Processing without Semantics? An Event-related Brain Potential Study of Preschoolers using Jabberwocky Sentences

Abstract

Abstract& Behavioral studies have demonstrated that children develop a nearly adult-like grammar between 36 and 42 months, but few studies have addressed how the child's brain processes semantic versus syntactic information. In previous research, Silva-Pereyra and colleagues showed that distinct event-related potentials (ERPs) are elicited by semantic and syntactic violations in sentences in children as young as 30, 36, and 48 months, following the patterns displayed by adults. In the current study, we examined ERPs to syntactic phrase structure violations in real and jabberwocky sentences in 36-month-old children. Jabberwocky sentences are sentences in which content (open-class) words are replaced by pseudowords while function (closed-class) words are retained. Results showed that syntactically anomalous real sentences elicited two positive ERP effects: left-distributed effects from 500 to 750 msec and 1050 to 1300 msec, whereas syntactically anomalous jabberwocky sentences elicited two negative ERP effects: a left-distributed effect from 750 to 900 msec and a later broadly distributed effect from 950 to 1150 msec. The results indicate that when preschoolers process real English sentences, ERPs resembling the positive effects previously reported for adults are noted, although at longer latencies and with broader scalp distributions. However, when preschoolers process jabberwocky sentences with altered lexical-semantic content, a negative-going ERP component similar to one typically associated with the extraction of meaning is noted. &

Neurocognitive mechanisms of statistical-sequential learning: what do event-related potentials tell us?

“…By 11 months of age, phonetic learning can already be observed; by 14 months, responses to known words are observed; and by 2.5 years, semantic and syntactic learning is elicited (Kuhl and Rivera-Gaxiola, 2008). For instance, a P600 to sentence-level syntactic violations has been found in 30, 36, and 48 months old children that looked rather similar to the P600 found in young adults (Silva-Pereyra et al, 2007). …”

Evolutionary origins of non-adjacent sequence processing in primate brain potentials

“…At least in human adults, this late positivity may involve or be related to the P3a, an ERP component seen with oddball paradigms414445. As a point of reference, late ERP components for syntactic processes do not seem to appear in children until the age of 2.5 to 3 years4647. In the nonhuman primates, the late positive ERP component that we label as a LP could be related to the reported P500 in macaques that responds to adjacent sequencing relationships38.…”

Toddlers encode similarities among novel words from meaningful sentences

“…It has been argued that the word-word associations that make up the class of color words are learned from how frequently those words are heard together in speech, and that these associations can bootstrap into the more specific word-color mapping that emerge later on (Sandhofer & Smith, 1999). Lastly, in an EEG study, 3-year-olds showed signatures of semantic processing when they heard sentences comprising novel content words and familiar function words (Silva-Pereya, Conboy, Klarman & Kuhl, 2007). This finding supports the interpretation that toddlers in the current experiment are extracting meaning from the training sentences, despite the presence of novel words.…”