Government purchasing initiatives involving private providers in the Eastern Mediterranean Region: a systematic review of impact on health service utilisation

Abstract

ObjectiveThis paper provides a systematic review of evidence of government purchase of health services from private providers through stand-alone contracting-out (CO) initiatives and CO insurance schemes (CO-I) on health service utilisation in Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR) to inform universal health coverage 2030 strategies.DesignSystematic review.Data sourcesElectronic search of published and grey literature on Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, PubMed, CINHAL, Google Scholar and web, including websites of ministries of health from January 2010 to November 2021.Eligibility criteriaRandomised controlled trials, quasi-experimental studies, time series, before–after and endline with comparison group reporting quantitative utilisation of data across 16 low-income and middle-income states of EMR. Search was limited to publications in English or English translation.Data extraction and synthesisWe planned for meta-analysis, but due to limited data and heterogeneous outcomes, descriptive analysis was performed.ResultsSeveral initiatives were identified but only 128 studies were eligible for full-text screening and 17 met the inclusion criteria. These included CO (n=9), CO-I (n=3) and a combination of both (n=5) across seven countries. Eight studies assessed interventions at national level and nine at subnational level. Seven studies reported on purchasing arrangements with non-governmental organisations, 10 on private hospitals and clinics. Impact on outpatient curative care utilisation was seen in both CO and CO-I, positive evidence of improved maternity care service volumes was seen mainly from CO interventions and less reported from CO-I, whereas data on child health service volume was only available for CO and indicated negative impact on service volumes. The studies also suggest pro-poor effect for CO initiatives, whereas there was scarce data for CO-I.ConclusionPurchasing involving stand-alone CO and CO-I interventions in EMR positively impact general curative care utilisation, but lacks conclusive evidence for other services. Policy attention is needed for embedded evaluations within programmes, standardised outcome metrics and disaggregated utilisation data.

Health workforce in the Eastern Mediterranean Region: From COVID‐19 lessons to actions

“…Private sector is becoming significant in employment of health workers, for example, private providers account for 70%-80% of ambulatory care visits in Afghanistan, Egypt, Lebanon, Pakistan and Somalia; 34%-45% in Iraq, Jordan, Sudan and Yemen and around 20% in the remaining countries and territories of the region. 11 At the same time, inadequate working conditions and working environments challenge the retention of health workers. The protracted crisis in almost half of the countries and economic crisis with deteriorating working conditions in many countries and territories have increased the international mobility of health workers.…”

“…On the demand side, the majority of countries are challenged by limited employment capacities due to financial and administrative limitations. Private sector is becoming significant in employment of health workers, for example, private providers account for 70%–80% of ambulatory care visits in Afghanistan, Egypt, Lebanon, Pakistan and Somalia; 34%–45% in Iraq, Jordan, Sudan and Yemen and around 20% in the remaining countries and territories of the region 11 …”

Health Workforce Shortages and Surpluses: The Case of Unsalaried Workers in Kurdistan Region of Iraq

“…The shortage of health workforce in is related to the lack of expansion in its size between 2013 and 2020 (Boniol et al, 2022). It is also driven by limited employment opportunities in both the public and private sectors with the latter becoming an increasingly signi cant employer (Zaidi et al, 2023).…”