Governance and Sector Outcomes: Making the Connections

Abstract

A critical issue in international development is how donor-funded programs can support sustainable and long-lasting changes in assisted countries. Among the factors associated with sustainability is improved governance. However, many donor-funded initiatives are focused on achieving results in specific sectors, such as health, education, and agriculture. How can how governance interventions contribute to achieving sector-specific results? This brief explores this question and discusses how international development practice has incorporated recognition of the links between governance and sector outcomes. The brief develops a stylized continuum of how governance elements relate to sector interventions and contribute to expected outcomes. We discuss factors that either impede or impel governance integration and close with some observations regarding prospects for integrated programming. The audience for the brief is the international development policy and practitioner communities, and secondarily, academics with an interest in the topic. Key take-aways include: (1) there is ample evidence of positive contributions from improved governance to sector-specific outcomes, but few guideposts exist for practical and effective governance integration; (2) barriers to integration include urgent sector priorities that overshadow governance concerns, requirements to demonstrate progress towards ambitious sector targets, and complex choices related to measurement; and (3) sustainability and self-reliance are major drivers for integration and are facilitated by the flexibility and adaptation that governance integration enables.

Transparency for Whom? Grounding Land Investment Transparency in the Needs of Local Actors

“…For instance, recent research highlights that more than one third of recorded attacks on human rights defenders in 2020 stemmed from failures to consult, or obtain the FPIC of, communities. 106 This risk illustrates the need to avoid relying on "decontextualized 'best practices'" 107 and to instead design and adapt transparency interventions to the relevant context.…”

“…These strategies and approaches need to be adjusted to-and their appropriateness will depend on-the local context, 178 taking into consideration potential risks to community members and their lands (see Part IV, above).…”

Stewardship and health systems strengthening: An overview

“…In its broadest theoretical conceptualization, governance refers to all processes of social organization and social coordination, encompassing non‐state actors and institutions as well as government (Bevir, ). Research on governance revealed the contribution of such processes to a range of outcomes and supported increased investments specifically designed to improve governance and inclusion of governance interventions in sector programs (Brinkerhoff & Wetterberg, ). However, confusion has persisted in response to the wide variety of governance definitions, models, and prescriptions, which offer few reliable guideposts for practitioners.…”

Integrated Governance: Achieving Governance Results and Contributing to Sector Outcomes

“…In an earlier analysis of integrated governance, our starting point for examining integration was sector projects and experts whose experiences with disappointing sector results led them to integrate governance components into their interventions. 2 For this study, however, we began from the perspective of governance projects and specialists that seek to contribute to sector outcomes. We recognize that many international development funders work in integrated governance.…”