Globalization and the growing defects of international economic statistics

Abstract

Official international economic statistics are generally considered accurate and meaningful gauges of cross-border flows of trade and capital. Most data users also assume that the quality of the underlying data keeps improving over time. Through an extensive review of the national accounting literature, archival research, two dozen interviews with high-level statisticians, and a series of data quality tests, we evaluate this common view for the primary source of data on trade and capital flows: the International Monetary Fund's Balance of Payments (BOP) Statistics. Our assessment paints a less rosy picture: reported figures are far less accurate than they are typically imagined to be and often do not correspond to the theoretical concepts with which users associate them. At the same time, measurement quality deteriorates over time as the transnationalization of economic production gradually undermines the validity of BOP statistics. Our findings raise serious questions about the widespread use of these numbers, with their deceptive pretense to accuracy, in scholarly research and public debate about the international political economy.

The rise of transnational state capital: state-led foreign investment in the 21st century

“…It allows us to determine the volume and weight of transnational state capital without relying on aggregated macroeconomic data like FDI-levels. This helps us to overcome the sizable issues related to the accuracy of macroeconomic indicators in times of globalization (Linsi & M€ ugge, 2019). By using fine-grained, firm-level data we focus on the actors themselves we seek to analyze, namely corporations and states.…”

Tracking finance flows towards assessing their consistency with climate objectives

“… In addition, building on country pilots, analytical bodies could put together aggregate-level indicators of investments and financing, here again making use of best-available data and estimation methods. Such estimates and indicators could substitute official statistics where adjustments in data collection processes are expected to be either very lengthy or not able to address growing limitations of traditional official statistics in the context of globalised economies ( (Linsi & Mügge, 2019)). The work of the IEA to estimate energy investments provides a reference point that could be deepened as well replicated in other sectors (IEA, 2018).…”

The Effect of Free Trade and The Economic Globalization toward Rupiah’s Stabilization

“…This relationship can be through trade, travel, investment, popular culture, and other forms of interaction to remove a limit on the country. Globalization is also a consequence of the ease in information, technology, and communication that has a broad impact on the political, cultural, social and economic fields [2].…”