“…Therefore, we confined our analysis to males. The 111 male cases with smoking data were found in 23 independent studies (Bendel & Ishak, 1961;Broderick et al, 1975;Dailey & Marcuse, 1969;DeAngelis et al, 1961;Flanagan & Roeckel, 1964;Friedberg, 1965;Gajaraj et al, 1971;Guillan & Zelman, 1966;Hathaway et al, 1969;Hellstrom & Fisher, 1963;Horie & Ohta, 1981;Kallenberg & Jaque, 1979;Kennedy, 1969;Lerner, 1967;Naib, 1961;Matsuo et al, 1986;Nash & Stout, 1958;Pfeffer & Stoven, 1978;Pfitzer & Knoblich, 1975;Shin et al, 1986;Thomas, 1962;Wang et al, 1976). (Although not reported as such in the publication, one woman in the study of Shin et al (1986) was a smoker, as were 8 of the 13 men; Shin, personal communication.…”