German packaging waste management: a successful voluntary agreement with less successful environmental effects

Abstract

The Duales System Deutschland (DSD) is an association of the German packaging industry to collect, sort and recycle packaging waste from consumers. While it can be called a ‘voluntary agreement’, it was established in response to the regulatory threat from the German Packaging Ordinance of imposing individual collection and recycling duties for every packaging producer and distributor. The DSD fulfils most of the conditions for a successful voluntary agreement. German packaging waste management is less successful in its environmental effects, however, as it prioritizes recycling over waste avoidance. Whereas avoidance can save the full resource and energy content of economized packages, recycling leads to a partial recovery of the natural resources and energy embodied in waste packages only. The EU Packaging Waste Directive follows the basic principle of the German Packaging Ordinance and systems similar to DSD have been established in other European countries. There is the danger that a specific form of packaging waste management becomes locked in which sets free an innovative potential for recycling technologies, but neglects a similar potential for waste avoidance. Copyright © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and ERP Environment

Trading Radical for Incremental Change: The Politics of a Circular Economy Transition in the German Packaging Sector

“…First, we suggest that the stakeholders' perceived fear of radical changes prevent successful circular economy transition politics. This explanation of the unambitious policy outcome of the Packaging Act builds further on the scholarly understanding of the relevant stakeholders, discussions, and underlying dynamics in the German packaging waste sector (Neumayer, 2000;Rasek & Smuda, 2018), while also adding to the scholarship on barriers for a circular economy. So far, scholars attribute the limited progress to a circular economy to a variety of cultural, regulatory, market and technological barriers (de Jesus & Mendonça, 2018;Kirchherr et al, 2018;Ritzén & Sandström, 2017).…”

Extended producer responsibility in Brazil: the case of tyre waste

“…Besides defining 'what' has to be done, statutes must also specify who does what, and establish obligations and responsibilities of each involved party [17,[23][24][25]. Third, monitoring should be systematic and regular to avoid free riding [17,22,23,25]. Finally, regulators must keep in mind that agreements are fragile mechanisms that need to be supported by additional policy decisions and initiatives [23].…”

Negotiated environmental agreements in promoting material efficiency in industry – first steps in Finland

“…They have been most popular in the fields of waste management and climate policy [14]. The NEAs reached in the waste management sector have been useful in promoting recycling, but they have not been that effective in promoting waste prevention [15].…”