Geographic barriers to care persist at the community healthcare level: Evidence from rural Madagascar

Abstract

Geographic distance is a critical barrier to healthcare access, particularly for rural communities with poor transportation infrastructure who rely on non-motorized transportation. There is broad consensus on the importance of community health workers (CHWs) to reduce the effects of geographic isolation on healthcare access. Due to a lack of fine-scale spatial data and individual patient records, little is known about the precise effects of CHWs on removing geographic barriers at this level of the healthcare system. Relying on a high-quality, crowd-sourced dataset that includes all paths and buildings in the area, we explored the impact of geographic distance from CHWs on the use of CHW services for children under 5 years in the rural district of Ifanadiana, southeastern Madagascar from 2018–2021. We then used this analysis to determine key features of an optimal geographic design of the CHW system, specifically optimizing a single CHW location or installing additional CHW sites. We found that consultation rates by CHWs decreased with increasing distance patients travel to the CHW by approximately 28.1% per km. The optimization exercise revealed that the majority of CHW sites (50/80) were already in an optimal location or shared an optimal location with a primary health clinic. Relocating the remaining CHW sites based on a geographic optimum was predicted to increase consultation rates by only 7.4%. On the other hand, adding a second CHW site was predicted to increase consultation rates by 31.5%, with a larger effect in more geographically dispersed catchments. Geographic distance remains a barrier at the level of the CHW, but optimizing CHW site location based on geography alone will not result in large gains in consultation rates. Rather, alternative strategies, such as the creation of additional CHW sites or the implementation of proactive care, should be considered.

Does Education Sculpt Healthcare Choices? Exploring Factors Influencing Healthcare Utilization Among Female Youths in Eight Low and Lower-Middle-Income Countries

“…This spatial distribution results in greater availability of medical services within close proximity in urban areas, facilitating prompt access. This may suggest that rural areas have fewer healthcare facilities, and individuals might need to travel more distances to reach the nearest center [34].…”

Tracking the cost of living, for whom and at what price? A political economy of price indicators in Madagascar

“…paid by households). 7 The third problem relates to the travel and waiting times required to access public services; these represent significant 'opportunity costs', which may change over time depending on the State of public administrations, roads, or climatic variations (Evans et al, 2022).…”

“…By way of example, health represents 1 % of expenditure in the Malagasy CPI basket, whereas according to the World Health Organization (WHO)'s sector accounts, in 2020, 34% of the country's health expenditures were "out-of-pocket expenditure" (i.e., paid by households) 7 . The third problem relates to the travel and waiting times required to access public services; these represent significant "opportunity costs", which may change over time depending on the State of public administrations, roads or climatic variations (Evans et al, 2022).…”

Mixed methods to evaluate knowledge, attitudes and practices (KAP) towards rabies in central and remote communities of Moramanga district, Madagascar

“…Access to health care is a major problem, including at very local scales such as the access to community health workers. Indeed, a recent study showed that the consultation rate of community health workers was reduced by 28.1% for each increase of 1 km in the distance with the patient’s house [ 19 ]. Similarly, access to PEP remains a major issue in Madagascar [ 12 ].…”