“…These discrepancies must result in part from variable contamination of garnet separates by inclusions (e.g., see Amato et al, 1999;Jung and Mezger, 2001, 2003a, 2003b, and possibly also from differences in Sm partitioning depending on mineral assemblage (e.g., Hickmott, 1988;Hickmott and Spear, 1992;Hermann, 2002;Thöni, 2002), much as is observed for Lu in metapelites vs. metabasites. Values in Table 1 are based on chronologic studies of leached garnets (Amato et al, 1999;Jung and Mezger, 2001, 2003a, 2003bAnczkiewicz et al, 2007), adjusted for trace element studies demonstrating somewhat stronger partitioning of Sm/Nd (Hickmott et al, 1987;Hickmott and Spear, 1992). These values and resulting Sm/Nd ratios are similar to those used by Lapen et al (2003) and at the upper end of values for metabasites and metapelites summarized by Thöni (2002), but 40 times lower than the value assumed by Skora et al (2006).…”