“…However, there is no consensus on the origin and source of the Lower Paleozoic gas, although it is generally considered as mixing gas (Cai et al, 2005;Dai et al, 2005;Li et al, 2003;Xia et al, 1999a;Zou et al, 2007). It is controversial on whether the gas is dominated by coal-derived gas from the Upper Paleozoic coal-measure source rocks (Hu and Zhang, 2011;Liu et al, 2016;Mi et al, 2012) or oil-associated gas from carbonate source rocks in the Ordovician Majiagou Formation (Cai et al, 2005;Chen, 2002;Liu et al, 2016) or Carboniferous Taiyuan Formation (Dai et al, 2005;Xia et al, 1999b). The disagreement mainly resulted from different understandings of the geochemical characteristics of the Lower Paleozoic gas and the effectiveness of Lower Paleozoic source rocks (Liu et al, 2016).…”