“…slab melting) may not be very important, and that fractionation, water activity, sulfur fugacity and the state of oxidation of the melt are the more critical components that dictate whether mineralization is to be generated or not in a particular adakitic suite (e.g. Kay and Mpodozis, 2001;Richard and Kerrich, 2007;Imai et al, 2009;Suerte et al, 2009;Jenner et al, 2010;Tanaka et al, 2010;Richards, 2011a, b;Chiaradia et al, 2012;Hronsky et al, 2012;Loucks, 2014). More complications arise when the role of mantle oxygen fugacity on crust-derived fluids or melts is considered (Chen et al, 2015).…”