Hypertension control may offer less protection from incident cardiovascular disease (CVDi) in adults with than without apparent treatment resistant hypertension (aTRH), i.e., blood pressure uncontrolled on ≥3 or controlled to <140/<90 on ≥4 antihypertensive medications. Electronic health data were matched to health claims for 2006–2012. Patients with CVDi in 2006–2007 or untreated hypertension were excluded leaving 118,356 treated hypertensives, including 40,690 aTRH patients, ) with 460,599 observation years. Blood pressure and medication number were determined by all clinic visit means from 2008 to CVDi or end of study. Primary outcome was first CVDi (stroke; coronary heart disease, heart failure) from hospital and emergency department claims. Controlling for age, race, sex, diabetes, chronic kidney disease, and statin use, hypertension control afforded less CVDi protection in patients with (hazard ratio 0.87, 95% confidence interval [0.82–0.93]) than without aTRH (0.69 [0.65–0.74]), p<0.001. Strategies beyond hypertension control may prevent more CVDi in aTRH.