20Because of their replication mode and segmented dsRNA genome, homologous recombination is assumed to be 21 rare in the rotaviruses. We analyzed 23,627 complete rotavirus genome sequences available in the NCBI Virus 22 35 36 37 65 a major factor in rotavirus evolution (23). Homologous recombination, however, is thought to be especially rare 66 in rotaviruses due to their dsRNA genomes (20, 21, 24). Unlike +ssRNA (25) viruses and DNA viruses (26), 67 dsRNA viruses are not easily able to undergo intragenic recombination because their genomes are not 68 transcribed in the cytoplasm by host polymerases, but rather within nucleocapsids by viral RNA-dependent 69 RNA polymerase (20, 27). Genome encapsidation should significantly reduce the opportunities for template 70 switching, the presumptive main mechanism of intramolecular recombination (26, 28).
71Despite the expectation that recombination should be rare in rotavirus A, there are nevertheless 72 numerous reports of recombination among rotaviruses in the literature (29)(30)(31)(32)(33)(34)(35)(36)(37). However, a comprehensive 73 4 survey of 797 rotavirus A genomes failed to find any instances of the same recombination event in multiple 74 samples (38). There are two possible explanations for this outcome. Either the putative recombinants were 75 spurious results stemming from poor analytical technique or were poorly fit recombinants that failed to increase 76 in frequency in the population such that they would be resampled (38). The main implications of this study are 77 that recombination among rotavirus A is rare and usually disadvantageous.
78Since the number of publicly available rotavirus A whole segment genomes is now over 23,600, it is 79 worth revisiting these conclusions to see if they are still valid. To this end, we used bioinformatics tools to 80 identify possible instances of recombination among all available complete rotavirus A genome sequences 81 available in the NCBI Virus Variation database as of May, 2019. We found strong evidence for recombination 82 events among all rotavirus A segments with the exception of NSP3 and NSP5. In several cases, the 83 recombinants were fixed in the population such that several hundred sampled strains showed remnants of this 84 same event. These reports suggest that rotavirus recombination occurs more frequently than is generally 85 appreciated, and can significantly influence rotavirus A evolution.
86
Methods
87
Sequence Acquisition and Metadata Curation
88We downloaded all complete rotavirus genomes from the Virus Variation Resource as of May 2019 89 (39). Laboratory strains were removed from the dataset. Genomes that appeared to contain substantial insertions 90 were excluded as well. Avian and mammalian strains were analyzed separately as recombination analyses 91 between more divergent genomes can sometimes confound the results. No well-supported events were identified 92 among the avian strains. For each rotavirus genome, separate fasta files were downloaded for each of the 11 93 segments. Metadata including...