Genetic diversity and delineation of Salmonella Agona outbreak strains by next generation sequencing, Bavaria, Germany, 1993 to 2018

Abstract

Background In 2017, a food-borne Salmonella Agona outbreak caused by infant milk products from a French supplier occurred in Europe. Simultaneously, S. Agona was detected in animal feed samples in Bavaria. Aim Using next generation sequencing (NGS) and three data analysis methods, this study’s objectives were to verify clonality of the Bavarian feed strains, rule out their connection to the outbreak, explore the genetic diversity of Bavarian S. Agona isolates from 1993 to 2018 and compare the analysis approaches employed, for practicality and ability to delineate outbreaks caused by the genetically monomorphic Agona serovar. Methods In this observational retrospective study, three 2017 Bavarian feed isolates were compared to a French outbreak isolate and 48 S. Agona isolates from our strain collections. The later included human, food, feed, veterinary and environmental isolates, of which 28 were epidemiologically outbreak related. All isolates were subjected to NGS and analysed by: (i) a publicly available species-specific core genome multilocus sequence typing (cgMLST) scheme, (ii) single nucleotide polymorphism phylogeny and (iii) an in-house serovar-specific cgMLST scheme. Using additional international S. Agona outbreak NGS data, the cluster resolution capacity of the two cgMLST schemes was assessed. Results We could prove clonality of the feed isolates and exclude their relation to the French outbreak. All approaches confirmed former Bavarian epidemiological clusters. Conclusion Even for S. Agona, species-level cgMLST can produce reasonable resolution, being standardisable by public health laboratories. For single samples or homogeneous sample sets, higher resolution by serovar-specific cgMLST or SNP genotyping can facilitate outbreak investigations.

Investigating Major Recurring Campylobacter jejuni Lineages in Luxembourg Using Four Core or Whole Genome Sequencing Typing Schemes

“…Molecular surveillance of foodborne pathogens is currently implemented for Salmonella ( Dangel et al., 2019 ), Listeria ( Van Walle et al., 2018 ), and VTEC ( Joensen et al., 2014 ) at the EU level ( ECDC, 2019 ) and in the USA ( Ribot et al., 2019 ). For C. jejuni , such monitoring in routine is hindered by the absence of a validated scheme at international level and the lack of evidence for the spread possibility of cross-border genotypes.…”

“…As a result, SNP analyses that compare strains at the nucleotide level tend to overestimate genetic exchange events and, consequently, decimate the signals of the Campylobacter population structure ( Sheppard et al., 2012 ). After conducting comparative studies between the SNP and the cgMLST approaches for different pathogens, it appears that the gene-by-gene approach is more suitable for identifying lineages with this recombining species ( Dangel et al., 2019 ; Jajou et al., 2019 ). This gene-by-gene method defines allelic profiles from a set of common loci, known as core genome common to a representative panel of isolates.…”

Detection of mobile genetic elements associated with antibiotic resistance in Salmonella enterica using a newly developed web tool: MobileElementFinder

“…If the average allele difference was equal to or lower than seven the selection was considered as clonal. 33 , 34…”

Toward an Integrated Genome-Based Surveillance of Salmonella enterica in Germany

“…Simultaneously, S. Agona was detected in three animal feed samples in Bavaria. In a retrospective WGS study, including the feed isolates and 48 additional S. Agona isolates (Bavarian isolates from 1993 to 2018), a connection between the feed isolates and the French outbreak was ruled out ( Dangel et al, 2019 ). Furthermore, the WGS approach confirmed clusters that were previously identified by epidemiological investigations and detected additional ones.…”