Erythropoiesis is one of the most demanding processes in the body, with more than 2 million red blood cells produced every second. Multiple hereditary and acquired red blood cell disorders arise from this complex system, with existing treatments effective in managing some of these conditions but few offering a long-term cure. Finding new treatments relies on the full understanding of the cellular and molecular interactions associated with the production and maturation of red blood cells, which take place within the erythroblastic island niche. The elucidation of processes associated within the erythroblastic island niche in health and during stress erythropoiesis has relied on in vivo modeling in mice, with complexities dissected using simple in vitro systems. Recent progress using state-of-the-art stem cell technology and gene editing has enabled a more detailed study of the human niche. Here, we review these different models and describe how they have been used to identify and characterize the cellular and molecular pathways associated with red blood cell production and maturation. We speculate that these systems could be applied to modeling red blood cell diseases and finding new druggable targets, which would prove especially useful for patients resistant to existing treatments. These models could also aid in research into the manufacture of red blood cells in vitro to replace donor blood transfusions, which is the most common treatment of blood disorders.