Generation Y New Zealand Registered Nurses’ views about nursing work: a survey of motivation and maintenance factors

Abstract

AimThe aim of this article was to report on the analysis of qualitative, open text data, received from a national on‐line survey of what factors Generation Y New Zealand Registered Nurses wish to change about nursing and consideration of the potential policy and practice impacts of these requests on their retention.BackgroundPrior to the economic recession of 2007–2010, the growing shortage of nurses in New Zealand presented a serious concern for the healthcare workforce. Given the ageing New Zealand nursing workforce, an ageing population and the increasing demands for health care, it is imperative that issues of retention of Generation Y nurses are resolved prior to the imminent retirement of more experienced nurses.DesignA descriptive exploratory approach using a national wide, on‐line survey, eliciting both quantitative and qualitative data was used.MethodThe survey, conducted from August 2009–January 2010, collected data from Generation Y New Zealand Registered Nurses (n = 358) about their views about nursing, work and career. Herzberg's Motivation‐Hygiene theory was used as the framework for the analysis of the open text data.ResultsThe factors that nurses wanted changed were skewed towards Herzberg's hygiene‐maintenance factors rather than motivating factors. This is of concern because hygiene‐maintenance factors are considered to be dissatisfiers that are likely to push workers to another employment option.

How do nurse managers describe clinical nurses' work arrangements? A qualitative study

“…As temporary arrangements increase the likelihood of temporary employees developing transactional rather than relational interactions with their employers (Van Breugel et al, ), nurses' experience of work time shapes the way they relate to their colleagues and vice versa. For instance, although nursing researchers have studied mentoring extensively and have reported that Millennial nurses in particular want ongoing mentoring and flexible careers (Hale, ; Jamieson, Kirk, Wright, & Andrew, ), the nursing scholarship sheds limited light on how alternative work arrangements affect mentoring as a communicative behaviour (Gan, ). As Millennial nurses will have increasingly diverse nursing career options (Jamieson et al, ), researchers should invest greater effort into understanding Millennial nurses' thoughts about alternative work arrangements.…”

Attitudes about work engagement of different generations—A cross‐sectional study with nurses and supervisors

“…Findings from international nursing studies describe the generation Y as dissatisfied, who expect better working conditions (Jamieson, Kirk, Wright, & Andrew, ; Wilson, Squires, Widger, Cranley, & Tourangeau, ) and are less resilient than generation X and baby boomers (Hakim, ). Some research has identified generation‐dependent variables for the generations Y, X and baby boomers concerning their wishes to stay in the nursing work force (Shacklock & Brunetto, ; Tourangeau, Thomson, Cummings, & Cranley, ).…”

“…Empirical studies on generation‐specific human resource management in the care sector have been conducted mostly in Australia, New Zealand and the United States (Anselmo‐Witzel, Orshan, Heitner, & Bachand, ; Christensen et al, ; Farr‐Wharton, Brunetto, & Shacklock, ; Jamieson et al, ; Sherman, ). Since no study has yet been conducted on the different generations' attitudes about working in health care and nursing in Germany, the present study sought to close this research gap and contribute to the discussion on managing according to specific generation characteristics in an international context.…”

The relationship between nurses' work‐related variables, colleague solidarity and job motivation

“…In contrast, nurses who exhibit benevolent behaviours are reported to have high motivation (Koch, Proynova, Paech, & Wetter, ). Additionally, a study conducted on Generation Y nurses, it was stated that improving the working conditions and relations between peers, both of which are among Herzberg's maintenance factors, and stopping negative attitudes and bullying were essential (Jamieson, Kirk, Wright, & Andrew, ). In today's health care system, respectful and collegial communication is essential (Cowin & Eagar, ) and nurses are expected to be reliable colleagues and team members in their organisational roles.…”