“…Moroever, chaos can also be applied at the coding level, as in the chaos-based direct-sequence code-division-multiple-access (DS-CDMA) schemes studied by Mazzini et al [5], Rovatti et al [6], and Chen et al [7]. In this case, since coherent communication is still applicable in the conventional sense at the waveform communication level [12], performance comparable to conventional systems can be achieved, and if further optimization at the coding level is possible with chaos, as demonstrated by Mazzini et al [5], Rovatti et al [6], improvement over existing DS-CDMA systems is also possible. In short, at the waveform level, all coherent schemes are impractical but their performances have benchmarking values; noncoherent schemes are more practical but their performances are inferior to conventional coherent systems.…”