General practitioners’ perceptions of distributed leadership in providing integrated care for elderly chronic multi-morbid patients: a qualitative study
Abstract:Background
Distributed Leadership (DL) has been suggested as being helpful when different health care professionals and patients need to work together across professional and organizational boundaries to provide integrated care (IC). This study explores whether General Practitioners (GPs) adopt leadership actions that transcend organizational boundaries to provide IC for patients and discusses whether the GPs’ leadership actions in collaboration with patients and health care professionals contr… Show more
“…Additionally, study findings show that delivering more holistic healthcare services will require digital correspondence that does not narrow the focus to the selected topics healthcare professionals consider relevant to each other. 19 In reference to the literature on distributed leadership, this finding is consistent with research suggesting that pluralized leadership has both collective and individual elements, and that collective leadership may need the support of both infrastructure and individual agency. 21–23 …”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 80%
“…Additionally, study findings show that delivering more holistic healthcare services will require digital correspondence that does not narrow the focus to the selected topics healthcare professionals consider relevant to each other. 19 In reference to the literature on distributed leadership, this finding is consistent with research suggesting that pluralized leadership has both collective and individual elements, and that collective leadership may need the support of both infrastructure and individual agency. [21][22][23] In addition, the study shows that if GPs limit their efforts to direction setting or only function as coordinators or implementors of medical tasks and interventions in isolation from the rest of the collective, this will limit the contribution the collective process has in creating a patient experience of integrated care.…”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 80%
“…Patients’ recollections and experiences of collaborating with their GP and home care nurses in day-to-day practice and during health deterioration were key themes of interviews. 19 Additionally, interviews focused on the patient’s efforts, actions, and thoughts on how to regain health and live as well as possible. Similarly, GP interviews focused on GPs’ experience from collaborating with other healthcare providers and the GPs’ recollections of the patient’s most recent hospitalization.…”
Objective
This study explores how the collaboration between elderly multimorbid patients and general practitioners contributes to the patient’s experience of integrated care in the municipality. The research also investigates whether the municipality’s integrative mechanisms creating integrated care can be understood as distributed leadership.
Method
In this qualitative study, we conducted a thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with twenty elderly multimorbid patients living at home and their general practitioners.
Results
Analysis of patients’ and general practitioners’ experience of healthcare service characterized by collective efforts identified four themes: 1) an impression of collective processes as difficult for patients to access and influence; 2) that the fluidity and location of leadership is dependent on the individual patient and his or her health condition; 3) that collective implementation of healthcare services is separated in time, geography and between organizations; and 4) that patients experience individual healthcare workers as specialized and unable to support the medical and holistic goals of the collective. The Direction, Alignment, and Commitment or DAC framework, is used to investigate the capabilities of the collective.
Conclusion
To promote distributed leadership and create a patient experience of integrated care in the municipality, healthcare organizations must develop collective processes that enhance patient participation to a greater extent. General practitioners and other healthcare personnel should be encouraged to play a more central role in solving elderly multimorbid patients’ healthcare needs in the municipality.
“…Additionally, study findings show that delivering more holistic healthcare services will require digital correspondence that does not narrow the focus to the selected topics healthcare professionals consider relevant to each other. 19 In reference to the literature on distributed leadership, this finding is consistent with research suggesting that pluralized leadership has both collective and individual elements, and that collective leadership may need the support of both infrastructure and individual agency. 21–23 …”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 80%
“…Additionally, study findings show that delivering more holistic healthcare services will require digital correspondence that does not narrow the focus to the selected topics healthcare professionals consider relevant to each other. 19 In reference to the literature on distributed leadership, this finding is consistent with research suggesting that pluralized leadership has both collective and individual elements, and that collective leadership may need the support of both infrastructure and individual agency. [21][22][23] In addition, the study shows that if GPs limit their efforts to direction setting or only function as coordinators or implementors of medical tasks and interventions in isolation from the rest of the collective, this will limit the contribution the collective process has in creating a patient experience of integrated care.…”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 80%
“…Patients’ recollections and experiences of collaborating with their GP and home care nurses in day-to-day practice and during health deterioration were key themes of interviews. 19 Additionally, interviews focused on the patient’s efforts, actions, and thoughts on how to regain health and live as well as possible. Similarly, GP interviews focused on GPs’ experience from collaborating with other healthcare providers and the GPs’ recollections of the patient’s most recent hospitalization.…”
Objective
This study explores how the collaboration between elderly multimorbid patients and general practitioners contributes to the patient’s experience of integrated care in the municipality. The research also investigates whether the municipality’s integrative mechanisms creating integrated care can be understood as distributed leadership.
Method
In this qualitative study, we conducted a thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with twenty elderly multimorbid patients living at home and their general practitioners.
Results
Analysis of patients’ and general practitioners’ experience of healthcare service characterized by collective efforts identified four themes: 1) an impression of collective processes as difficult for patients to access and influence; 2) that the fluidity and location of leadership is dependent on the individual patient and his or her health condition; 3) that collective implementation of healthcare services is separated in time, geography and between organizations; and 4) that patients experience individual healthcare workers as specialized and unable to support the medical and holistic goals of the collective. The Direction, Alignment, and Commitment or DAC framework, is used to investigate the capabilities of the collective.
Conclusion
To promote distributed leadership and create a patient experience of integrated care in the municipality, healthcare organizations must develop collective processes that enhance patient participation to a greater extent. General practitioners and other healthcare personnel should be encouraged to play a more central role in solving elderly multimorbid patients’ healthcare needs in the municipality.
“…All residents in Norway have the right to a GP. GPs are employed at different GP offices within the municipality, which are open during the day from Monday to Friday [ 37 ]. In addition, municipalities are responsible for emergency services, such as local emergency rooms that are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.…”
Section: Methodsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…In addition, municipalities are responsible for emergency services, such as local emergency rooms that are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Citizens in a municipality who need acute treatment are either referred to the local intermunicipal acute inpatient care (AIC) unit or the nearby regional hospital [ 37 ].…”
Background
Owing to the demographic changes in the elderly population worldwide, delivering coordinated care at home to multimorbid older adults is of great importance. Older adults living with multiple chronic conditions need information to manage and coordinate their care. eHealth can be effective for gaining sufficient information, communicating, and self-managing chronic conditions. However, incorporating older adults’ health preferences and ensuring active involvement remain challenging. More knowledge is needed to ensure successful participation and eHealth use in care coordination.
Objective
This study aimed to explore multimorbid older adults’ experiences with participation and eHealth in care coordination with general practitioners (GPs) and district nurses (DNs).
Methods
The study had a qualitative explorative approach. Data collection included semistructured interviews with 20 older adults with multimorbidity receiving primary care services from their GPs and DNs. The participants were included by their GPs or nurses at a local intermunicipal acute inpatient care unit. The data analysis was guided by systematic text condensation.
Results
We identified 2 categories: (1) older adults in charge of and using eHealth in care coordination, and (2) older adults with a loss of control in care coordination. The first category describes how communication with GPs and DNs can facilitate participation, the importance of managing own medication, and how eHealth can support older adults’ information needs. The second category focuses on older adults who depend on guidance and help from their GPs and DNs to manage their health, describing how a lack of capacity and system support to be involved makes these adults lose control of their care coordination.
Conclusions
Being in charge of care coordination is important for older multimorbid adults. The results show that older adults are willing to use eHealth to be informed and to seek information, which ensures high levels of participation in care coordination. Future research should investigate how older adults can be involved in electronic information sharing with health care providers.
BACKGROUND
Due to the demographic changes in the elderly population worldwide, delivering coordinated care at home to multimorbid older adults is of great importance. Older adults living with multiple chronic conditions need information to manage and coordinate their care. eHealth can be effective for gaining sufficient information, communication, and self-management of chronic conditions for the elderly. There is a need for more knowledge on how multimorbid older adults participate in coordinating their care and for a better understanding of how eHealth supports their participation.
OBJECTIVE
This study aims to 1) gain knowledge on multimorbid older adults’ experiences with participation in care coordination with the general practitioner (GP) and district nurses (DNs), and 2) explore how eHealth supports their participation in care coordination.
METHODS
The study has a qualitative explorative approach. Data collection included semi-structured interviews with 20 older adults with multimorbidity receiving primary care services from their GPs and DNs. The participants were included by their GP or a nurse at a local inter-municipal acute inpatient care (AIC) unit. The data analysis was guided by systematic text condensations (STC).
RESULTS
We identified two categories: 1) Older adults in charge of and using eHealth to coordinate their care, 2) older adults with a loss of control to coordinate their care. The first category describes how communication with the GP and DNs can facilitate participation, the importance of managing own medication, and how eHealth can support older adults' information needs. The second category focuses on older adults who depend on guidance from their GP and DNs to manage their health, describing how lack of the capacity to be involved in information sharing makes these adults lose control of their care coordination.
CONCLUSIONS
Being in charge of care coordination is important for the elderly. Future research should lead to understanding of electronic information sharing among healthcare providers, as older adults experience a lack of involvement in the information sharing, which hampers participation. The results show that older adults are willing to use eHealth to be informed and seek information, which enables participation in care coordination.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.