Gene–environment interactions influence ecological consequences of transgenic animals

Abstract

Production of transgenic animals has raised concern regarding their potential ecological impact should they escape or be released to the natural environment. This concern has arisen mainly from research on laboratory-reared animals and theoretical modeling exercises. In this study, we used biocontained naturalized stream environments and conventional hatchery environments to show that differences in phenotype between transgenic and wild genotypes depend on rearing conditions and, critically, that such genotype-by-environment interactions may influence subsequent ecological effects in nature. Genetically wild and growth hormone transgenic coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) were reared from the fry stage under either standard hatchery conditions or under naturalized stream conditions. When reared under standard hatchery conditions, the transgenic fish grew almost three times longer than wild conspecifics and had (under simulated natural conditions) stronger predation effects on prey than wild genotypes (even after compensation for size differences). In contrast, when fish were reared under naturalized stream conditions, transgenic fish were only 20% longer than the wild fish, and the magnitude of difference in relative predation effects was much reduced. These data show that genotype-by-environment interactions can influence the relative phenotype of transgenic and wild-type organisms and that extrapolations of ecological consequences from phenotypes developed in the unnatural laboratory environment may lead to an overestimation or underestimation of ecological risk. Thus, for transgenic organisms that may not be released to nature, the establishment of a range of highly naturalized environments will be critical for acquiring reliable experimental data to be used in risk assessments.coho salmon ͉ phenotypic plasticity ͉ risk-assessment

Metabolism traits of ‘all-fish’ growth hormone transgenic common carp (Cyprinus carpio L.)

“…Consequently, transgenic common carp released into a natural ecosystem may adjust to naturally occurring food shortages by reducing energy expenditures by decreasing activity and lowering metabolic rate as control carp do. Although the risk of extrapolating laboratory data to ecological risks should be carefully considered (Devlin et al, 2004;Sundström et al, 2007), these physiological traits have important ecological significance for transgenic carp in natural waters.…”

Transgenic Salmon: Science, Politics, and Flawed Policy

“…Although these effects would have the potential to influence wild relatives both directly and indirectly, such observations were demonstrably muted when the GE fish were reared under simulated natural conditions (Sundström et al, 2007), indicating the complexity of gene-environment interactions. The extent to which this information on GE coho salmon can predict the behavior of GE Atlantic salmon is also unknown.…”

Safety, Security and Quality: Lessons from GMO Risk Assessments

“…However, in natural conditions, what are the real availabilities of food for any escaped GM Salmon? Sundström et al (2007) compared salmon raised in tanks with salmon raised in an environment simulating natural conditions. The GM Coho Salmon grow larger, up to three times longer than the wild type.…”