Gendered Expectations: Examining How Peers Shape Female Students' Intent to Pursue STEM Fields

Abstract

Building on prior psychological and sociological research on the power of local environments to shape gendered outcomes in STEM fields, this study focuses on the critical stage of adolescence to explore the potential negative impact of exposure to exclusionary messages from peers within girls' science classrooms, as well as the positive potential impact of inclusionary messages. Specifically, utilizing longitudinal data from a diverse sample of adolescent youth, analyses examine how the presence of biased male peers, as well as confident female peers, shape girls' subsequent intentions to pursue different STEM fields, focusing specifically on intentions to pursue the male-dominated fields of computer science and engineering, as well as more gender equitable fields. Results reveal that exposure to a higher percentage of 8th grade male peers in the classroom who endorsed explicit gender/STEM stereotypes significantly and negatively predicted girls' later intentions to pursue a computer science/engineering (CS/E) major. Yet results also reveal that exposure to a higher percentage of confident female peers in the science classroom positively predicted such intentions. These results were specific to CS/E majors, suggesting that peers are an important source of messages regarding whether or not girls should pursue non-traditional STEM fields. This study calls attention to the importance of examining both positive and negative sources of influence within the local contexts where young people live and learn. Limitations and directions for future research are also discussed.

Gender norms and STEM: the importance of friends for stopping leakage from the STEM pipeline

“…Studies that consider gender norms and focus on a more immediate environment, such as Robnett and Leaper (2013;US), suggest thatin line with H2Agirls are less interested in STEM careers when their friend group does not support STEM and is predominantly comprised of members of the same sex. Other studies, contrary to H2A or H2B, find that a male-dominated environment enforces traditional gender norms among girls (Dasgupta et al, 2015;Riegle-Crumb & Morton, 2017). For instance, Dasgupta et al (2015) concluded from an experiment that implicit masculine stereotypes about engineering led to less engineering career aspirations among women who were assigned to primarily opposite-sex (male-dominated) groups.…”

Gender Role in Saudi Arabian Female High School English Textbooks Traveller 1 and Traveller 2

“…In addition, most scholars have agreed that local environments and other venues of everyday social interactions such as homes, schools and religious places are the most powerful ways to construct the gender roles (Riegle-Crumb & Morton, 2017). Those places are usually the first venues to construct gender roles and 'subsequently remind' individuals of what is appropriate and expected norms and behaviors of a certain gender (Risman, 2004).…”

A Summary of Effective Gender Equitable Teaching Practices in Informal STEM Education Spaces

“…But to fully support girls from diverse backgrounds, including girls of color in STEM, we need to move beyond inclusion and incorporate culturally responsive teaching (Brown, 2017;Gay, 2013;Ladson-Billings, 2008;. Future stud-they grow older and stereotypes are reinforced by parents, peers and educators (Hazari et al, 2015;Riegle-Crumb and Morton, 2017;Tan et al, 2013). In addition, our culture recognizes certain fields as being legitimate STEM disciplines (e.g.…”