Gender Differences in and the Relationships Between Social Anxiety and Problematic Internet Use: Canonical Analysis

Abstract

BackgroundThe cognitive-behavioral model of problematic Internet use (PIU) proposes that psychological well-being is associated with specific thoughts and behaviors on the Internet. Hence, there is growing concern that PIU is associated with psychological impairments.ObjectiveGiven the proposal of gender schema theory and social role theory, men and women are predisposed to experience social anxiety and engage in Internet use differently. Thus, an investigation of gender differences in these areas is warranted. According to the cognitive-behavioral model of PIU, social anxiety is associated with specific cognitions and behaviors on the Internet. Thus, an investigation of the association between social anxiety and PIU is essential. In addition, research that takes into account the multidimensional nature of social anxiety and PIU is lacking. Therefore, this study aimed to explore multivariate gender differences in and the relationships between social anxiety and PIU.MethodsParticipants included 505 college students, of whom 241 (47.7%) were women and 264 (52.3%) were men. Participants’ ages ranged from 18 to 22 years, with a mean age of 20.34 (SD=1.16). The Social Anxiety Scale and Problematic Internet Use Scale were used in data collection. Multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) and canonical correlation analysis were used.ResultsMean differences between men and women were not statistically significant in social anxiety (λ=.02, F3,501=2.47, P=.06). In all three PIU dimensions, men scored higher than women, and MANOVA shows that multivariate difference was statistically significant (λ=.94, F3,501=10.69, P<.001). Of the canonical correlation functions computed for men, only the first was significant (Rc=.43, λ=.78, χ29=64.7, P<.001) and accounted for 19% of the overlapping variance. Similarly, only the first canonical function was significant for women (Rc=.36, λ=.87, χ29=33.9, P<.001), which accounted for 13% of the overlapping variance.ConclusionsOn the basis of the findings, we conclude that enhanced educational opportunities for women and their increasing role in the society have led women to become more active and thus closed the gap in social anxiety levels between men and women. We found that men showed more difficulties than women in terms of running away from personal problems (ie, social benefit), used the Internet more excessively, and experienced more interpersonal problems with significant others due to Internet use. We conclude that men are under a greater risk of social impairments due to PIU. Our overall conclusion is that there is a substantial amount of association between social anxiety and PIU and the association is stronger for men than it is for women. We advise that future research continue to investigate PIU and social anxiety as multidimensional constructs.

Factors Affecting User Acceptance in Overuse of Smartphones in Mobile Health Services: An Empirical Study Testing a Modified Integrated Model in South Korea

“…Future research is being planned that actually applies the findings of this study and implements the SOMS to investigate health-related outcomes. Future research should also include further investigation of the difference in perception between genders regarding the acceptance of the app, since the possibility of a difference has been suggested in previous research (34).…”

Fear of Missing Out and Smartphone Addiction Mediates the Relationship Between Positive and Negative Affect and Sleep Quality Among Chinese University Students

“…Some studies have reported that negative events impacting on sleep quality mainly included bad dormitory conditions (e.g., noisy roommates, snoring, gaming, lighting, mosquitos), interpersonal conflict, academic pressure, freshmen maladjustment, as well as romantic relationship problems) ( 102 , 103 ). Due to specific characteristics of smartphones (e.g., the many different types of applications), smartphones can be considered as tools that provide self-comfort and satisfy basic need of communication with others in a timely way (i.e., individuals, especially females prefer texting, blogging and chatting via smartphone) ( 104 – 106 ). Consequently, all kinds of messages from Chinese SNSs such as WeChat and QQ (e.g., different groups comprising class, grade, students’ union, different courses, etc.)…”

Associations between problematic Internet use and psychiatric symptoms among university students in Japan

“…Baloǧlu et al . suggest that as levels of social anxiety increase and people spend less time in real‐life relationships and more time on the Internet, their risk of developing PIU becomes greater . Many studies have shown a relation between PIU and ADHD .…”

“…51 Baloǧlu et al suggest that as levels of social anxiety increase and people spend less time in real-life relationships and more time on the Internet, their risk of developing PIU becomes greater. 52 Many studies have shown a relation between PIU and ADHD. [53][54][55] Regardless of PIU, many reports indicate that ADHD is related to behavior dependence, such as substance-related dependence and gambling dependence.…”