Gender Differences in Alcohol Demand: A Systematic Review of the Role of Prices and Taxes

Abstract

Gender differences in drinking patterns are potentially important for public policies, especially policies that rely extensively on higher alcohol taxes and prices. This paper presents a systematic review of alcohol prices and gender differences in drinking and heavy drinking by adults and young adults. Starting with a database of 578 studies of alcohol demand and other outcomes, 15 studies are reviewed of adult drinking including discussion of samples, measurement issues, econometric models, special variables, and key empirical results. A similar discussion is presented for eight studies of drinking by young adults, ages 18–26 years. Four conclusions are obtained from the review. First, adult men have less elastic demands compared with women. Second, there is little or no price response by heavy‐drinking adults, regardless of gender. Third, although the sample is small, price might be important for drinking participation by young adults. Fourth, the results strongly suggest that heavy drinking by young adults, regardless of gender, is not easily dissuaded by higher prices. Policy implications, primary study limitations, and suggestions for future research are discussed. Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Changes in wine consumption are influenced most by health: results from a population survey of South Australians in 2013

“…49,50 This suggestion was supported by the finding of this study for wine. This study found that although heavy consumers had mainly maintained (43.1%) or decreased (44.5%) their consumption over the previous 12 months, health (46.3%) was cited as the most important reason for change, while price was much less frequently given as a reason (5.6%).…”

Europe. An Analysis of Changes in the Consumption of Alcoholic Beverages: The Interaction Among Consumption, Related Harms, Contextual Factors and Alcoholic Beverage Control Policies

“…Contrary to a substantial literature (see, among others, Meier, Purshouse and Brennan, 2010;Patra et al, 2012;Osterberg 2012b), but in keeping with a few other studies (Mohler-Kuo et al, 2004;Nelson, 2013) our study was not able to find any relevance of price impacting alcoholic beverage consumption. According to TS, no correlation was found between total alcoholic beverage consumption and price of both 1st and 2nd preferred country beverage, while ANN-based analysis showed that in the Northern European countries, where there was only a weak connection between wine price and both wine and beer increased consumption.…”

“…On the other hand, after the abolition of travellers' allowances for alcoholic beverage imports into Denmark, Sweden, and Finland in 2004, and the lowering of excise taxes on alcoholic beverages in 2003-2005 in Denmark and in 2004 in Finland, the prevalence of alcoholic beverage consumptionrelated problems mainly decreased over the study period (Bloomfield, Wicki, Gustafsson, Mäkelä, & Room, 2010). Moreover, doubts have been repeatedly raised about the effectiveness of both prices and taxation on all types of beverages and on all types of drinkers (among others see Mohler-Kuo, Rehm, Heeb, & Gmel, 2004;Nelson, 2013). The enforcement of measures and their interplay with informal control may greatly vary according to both countries and cultures, making it difficult to attempts to measure and compare the effects of similar interventions in different areas (Karlsson, Lindeman, &Österberg, 2012).…”

Meta-Analysis of Alcohol Price and Income Elasticities – With Corrections for Publication Bias

“…Even if the distribution of consumption is lognormal, it does not follow that responses to prices are uniform across subpopulations of drinkers. Available evidence from survey studies indicates that demands by heavy drinkers are less responsive to price compared to the general population [39,40]. While many moderate drinkers probably respond to changes in prices of most alcohol beverages, it does not follow that an across-theboard price or taxation policy will directly reduce heavy drinking.…”