Gender and the Clinical Usefulness of the Albumin:Creatinine Ratio

Abstract

One hundred and eighty-seven diabetic and 105 control subjects collected timed overnight urine samples to measure the inter-individual variation in creatinine excretion rate and its determinants, and to test the relationship between albumin excretion rate (AER) and two 'surrogate measures', the albumin concentration and albumin:creatinine ratio. Creatinine excretion was 55% higher in men than women (geometric mean 8.9 mumol min-1 (95% confidence limits 4.7-17.0) compared with 5.7 (3.0-10.9); p < 0.001). Gender accounted for 31% of the variation in creatinine excretion and body mass index 1.4%; neither age nor the diabetic state had a significant effect. The relationships between AER and the two surrogate measures differed between diabetic subjects and controls such that relationships constructed from non-diabetic data would not hold true for diabetes. Likewise, the relationship between AER and albumin:creatinine ratio differed between men and women such that a ratio of 4.0 mg mmol-1 corresponded to a predicted AER of 35 micrograms min-1 in men and 23 micrograms min-1 in women. The albumin:creatinine ratio outperformed albumin concentration in terms of sensitivity and specificity and its performance was better in women than men. We conclude that the albumin:creatinine ratio is a better surrogate for AER than albumin concentration. If 'action levels' are to be defined for screening programmes, they should be derived from diabetic and not non-diabetic data and should be different in men and women. We propose a direct rather than screening role for the albumin:creatinine ratio in the management of diabetic nephropathy.

Influence of first morning urine volume, fasting blood glucose and glycosylated hemoglobin on first morning urinary albumin concentration

“…Therefore, the variability of urinary volume should not result in the misclassification of diabetic patients for screening purposes. Some reports have described the possible influence of volume on albumin concentration in first morning or overnight urine samples (9,14,15) and, although we agree with them, the variability which we have found was minimal and not constant for our patient sample.…”

“…Recently, 6% of bacteriuria more than 100,000/mm 3 has been found in a randomly selected subset of 33 diabetic patients. These subjects, aged more than 60 years, were not excluded from screening for microalbuminuria (14). Our sample was comprised of younger patients and only those with IDDM.…”

Optimal strategies for identifying kidney disease in diabetes: properties of screening tests, progression of renal dysfunction and impact of treatment – systematic review and modelling of progression and cost-effectiveness

“…Because women excrete less creatinine than men, clinicians in the UK use different ACR thresholds for diagnosing microalbuminuria in men and women. 17 Are tests to detect the onset of microalbuminuria reliable?…”

Analysis of Therapeutic Outcome of Antidiabetic Medications in a Tertiary Care Hospital - An Observational Study

“…Errors due to improper collection methods and variations in 24-h protein excretion compared with a random urine specimen. The ADA and the National Kidney Foundation define micro albuminuria as an ACR between 30 to 300 g/mg in both men and women [18,19].…”