Gender-Affirming Surgery for Transgender Individuals: Perceived Satisfaction and Barriers to Care

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to examine the perceived satisfaction and barriers to care for transgender patients after they decide to undergo gender-affirming surgery (GAS). Method: A survey consisting of 21 multiple-choice and short-answer questions was distributed to transgender organizations and online forums across Canada and the United States. The data were then analyzed using descriptive statistics. Results: There were 32 participants, 12 who identified as female to male and 20 as male to female. The mean age was 36 years, with a range of 18 to 81 years. The mean age of their first GAS was 33 years, and the range of wait time was 6 months to 7 years. Most of the participants received information about GAS from transgender websites and transgender surgery clinics (91% and 50%, respectively). Most participants (74%) felt like they had access to appropriate care and 89% felt like their surgeons provided enough information about GAS. There were 38% of participants who would change their experience with GAS. Participants stated several barriers toward receiving GAS: financial (73%), finding a physician (65%), and access to information (63%). Surgical transition was important to the quality of life for 91% of participants and 100% were happy with their decision to undergo GAS. Conclusions: Transgender participants demonstrated that GAS is important to their quality of life and this study showed significant barriers to GAS. Résumé Objectif : La présenteétude visait à examiner la perception de satisfaction et d'obstacles aux soins de la part des patients transgenres après qu'ils ont décidé de subir une opération de réassignation de genre (ORG). Méthodologie : Les chercheurs ont distribué un sondage composé de 21 questions à choix multiple et à réponse courte aux organisations transgenres et aux forums en ligne du Canada et des États-Unis. Ils ont ensuite analysé les données à l'aide de statistiques descriptives. Résultats : Au total, 32 personnes ont participé au sondage. Douze se sont identifiés comme hommes trans et 20, comme femmes trans. Ils avaient un âge moyen de 36 ans (plage de 18 à 81 ans). Ils avaient un âge moyen de 33 ans lors de leur première ORG et avaient dû attendre de six mois à sept ans pour la subir. La plupart des participants avaient reçu de l'information au sujet de l'ORG dans des sites pour les personnes transgenres et des cliniques chirurgicales de réassignation de genre (91 % et 50 %, respectivement). La plupart des participants (74 %) trouvaient qu'ils avaient eu accès à des soins appropriés et 89 % trouvaient que leur chirurgien leur avait fourni assez d'information sur l'ORG. Cependant, 38 % des participants auraient modifié leur expérience de l'ORG. Les participants ont souligné plusieurs obstacles à l'ORG : la question financière (73 %), la quête d'un médecin (65 %) et l'accès à l'information (63 %). La transition chirurgicaleétait importante pour la qualité de vie de 91 % des participants et ilsétaient tous heureux d'avoir subi une ORG. Conclusions : Les participants transgenres ont ...

Evaluating Patient Benefit From Laryngochondroplasty

“…A study by El‐Hadi et al in 2018 looked at barriers to care for transgender patients within the United States and Canada. In the study, there was a varied length of wait times for surgery ranging from 6 months to 7 years 31 . In this study, the average wait time between date of first visit and date of surgery was 95.7 days, with a standard deviation of ±84.2 days and a range of 3 to 503 days.…”

“…Having all providers and referrals within a single system may explain why the average wait time is so different than that reported by El‐Hadi et al Moreover, laryngochondroplasty is a covered benefit for all qualified transgender patients within KP NCAL. Participants in the El‐Hadi et al study stated several barriers toward receiving gender‐affirming surgery including financial (73%), finding a physician (65%), and access to information (63%) 31 …”

Impact of Mastectomy on Body Image and Sexuality from a LGBTQ Perspective: A Narrative Review

“…Besides a surgical aspect, one year of testosterone therapy positively showed an increase of libido and masturbation in transmen after sexual reassignment surgery [ 25 ]. Gender-affirming surgery allows transmen patients to reach a high level of satisfaction and improved quality of life [ 26 ]. Mastectomy is, therefore, a favorable procedure that mostly has an overall positive impact on sexuality in transmen.…”

Breast augmentation in the transgender patient: narrative review of current techniques and complications

“…Estimates often come from single institution data, which are then extrapolated to state-wide or nation-wide scales (3). These numbers only capture data on patients who both have access to transgender-specific healthcare and experience gender dysphoria to a degree in which transgender-specific healthcare is required (3)(4)(5). Gender dysphoria can be defined as the discrepancy between assigned sex at birth and gender identity that leads to discomfort or distress (3).…”