Gamification for health promotion: systematic review of behaviour change techniques in smartphone apps

Abstract

ObjectiveSmartphone games that aim to alter health behaviours are common, but there is uncertainty about how to achieve this. We systematically reviewed health apps containing gaming elements analysing their embedded behaviour change techniques.MethodsTwo trained researchers independently coded apps for behaviour change techniques using a standard taxonomy. We explored associations with user ratings and price.Data sourcesWe screened the National Health Service (NHS) Health Apps Library and all top-rated medical, health and wellness and health and fitness apps (defined by Apple and Google Play stores based on revenue and downloads). We included free and paid English language apps using ‘gamification’ (rewards, prizes, avatars, badges, leaderboards, competitions, levelling-up or health-related challenges). We excluded apps targeting health professionals.Results64 of 1680 (4%) health apps included gamification and met inclusion criteria; only 3 of these were in the NHS Library. Behaviour change categories used were: feedback and monitoring (n=60, 94% of apps), reward and threat (n=52, 81%), and goals and planning (n=52, 81%). Individual techniques were: self-monitoring of behaviour (n=55, 86%), non-specific reward (n=49, 82%), social support unspecified (n=48, 75%), non-specific incentive (n=49, 82%) and focus on past success (n=47, 73%). Median number of techniques per app was 14 (range: 5–22). Common combinations were: goal setting, self-monitoring, non-specific reward and non-specific incentive (n=35, 55%); goal setting, self-monitoring and focus on past success (n=33, 52%). There was no correlation between number of techniques and user ratings (p=0.07; rs=0.23) or price (p=0.45; rs=0.10).ConclusionsFew health apps currently employ gamification and there is a wide variation in the use of behaviour change techniques, which may limit potential to improve health outcomes. We found no correlation between user rating (a possible proxy for health benefits) and game content or price. Further research is required to evaluate effective behaviour change techniques and to assess clinical outcomes.Trial registration numberCRD42015029841.

Mobile Healthcare Applications and Gamification for Sustained Health Maintenance

“…Relatedness is a psychological need in SDT to enhance motivation by having a feeling of connection with others [36]. According to Edwards, et al [37], top-rated healthcare applications are identified to apply individual behavior change techniques and the combinations of the techniques, which are based on the PENS model. Therefore, we propose one hypothesis that includes the effects of these three factors on enjoyment.…”

The promise of an augmented reality game—Pokémon GO

“…For example, SuperBetter includes tailored educational elements based on HBT, such as individualized assistance and feedback on each player's achievement/improvement. Systematic reviews report that the most prevalent theoretical constructs of health intervention games were self-monitoring, goal setting, and self-reward (6,9). Health interventions, which are designed based on theoretical frameworks, are likely to lead to longer behavior change (7).…”

Behavior change types with Pokémon GO

“…the "process of gamification" [1], has become increasingly common in different contexts, for example, health and exercise. The common aim of gamification is to motivate people to behave in desired ways through more gameful and enjoyable user experiences [2], and gamification can be effective in promoting and sustaining healthy behaviors [3]. Different gamification strategies can be applied through novel or existing games [4] and those strategies often share central features with established health behavior change techniques [5].…”