Games of risk and reward in carnivore communities

Abstract

Mesopredator release theory suggests that dominant predators suppress subordinate carnivores and ultimately shape community dynamics, but the assumption that subordinate species are only negatively affected ignores the possibility of facilitation through scavenging. We examined the interplay within a carnivore community consisting of cougars, coyotes, black bears, and bobcats using contemporaneous Global Positioning System telemetry data from 51 individuals, diet analysis from 972 DNA-metabarcoded scats, and data from 128 physical investigations of cougar kill sites, 28 of which were monitored with remote cameras. Resource provisioning from competitively-dominant cougars to coyotes through scavenging was so prolific as to be an overwhelming determinant of coyote behavior, space use, and resource acquisition. This was evident via strong attraction of coyotes to cougar kill sites, frequent scavenging of cougar-killed prey, and coyote diets that nearly matched cougars in the magnitude of ungulate consumption. Yet coyotes were often killed by cougars and used space to minimize encounters, complicating the fitness benefits gained from scavenging. We estimated that 23% (95% CI: 8–55%) of the coyote population in our study area was killed by cougars annually suggesting that coyote interactions with cougars are a complex behavioral game of risk and reward. In contrast, we found no indication that bobcat space use or diet was influenced by cougars. Black bears avoided cougars, but there was no evidence of attraction to cougar kill sites, and much lower levels of ungulate consumption and carcass visitation than for coyotes. Interspecific interactions among carnivores are multifaceted encompassing both suppression and facilitation.Significance StatementAn incomplete understanding of the total influence top predators exert on subordinate species hinders our ability to anticipate the effects that changing carnivore populations will have in ecological communities. Here we show that cougars are the architects of a complex behavioral game of risk and reward, as subordinate or co-occurring carnivores are both provisioned and preyed on by the top predators. Each co-occurring carnivore species considered here employed a different strategy to approach the risk-reward tradeoff suggesting there are multiple viable solutions to the game. By not considering the multitude of effects top predators have on other carnivores, we are missing important linkages in terrestrial food webs.