“…First of all, Stewart, et al stated in the introduction that their group was the first to identify bacterial microcolonies in pigment stones. 1 Actually, the presence of bacterial microcolonies was first documented by SEM, both in the center and in the periphery of brown stones, in our paper 3 1 year before their paper on microcolonies. 4 In addition, we would like to stress, on the basis of our prospective study on 2,000 consecutive patients with gallstones 5 and who had systematic analysis of bile and stones, that even if bacterial microcolonies could be sometimes present in other types of stones, it is important to consider cholesterol or mixed stones from one hand, and entirely brown stones on the other hand, as two distinct entities for both epidemiological/pathophysiological and clinical purposes.…”