Alumina–tantalum composites are produced in a two‐step synthesis via cold isostatic pressing (CIP) from commercially available raw materials without any addition of organic additives. The highest densification for fine‐grained composites is found with a maximum pressure of 150 MPa, whereby a cyclic pressure increase or at maximum pressure showed no measurable influence. The increase of the sintering temperature from 1600 to 1700 °C led to a higher densification up to a relative density of 75.8%. Aggregates received by jawbreaking show a blocky morphology, rounded corners, and edges with porosities of 6.2−7.3%. The formation of tantalum carbide and the incorporation of oxygen into the tantalum lattice are verified during sintering. The coarse‐grained composites produced from these aggregates show open porosities of 25.3−25.7% and shrinkage <0.5%. Determined splitting tensile strenghts are in the range between 8.4 and 9.1 MPa.