From wheel of fortune to wheel of misfortune: Financial crises, cycles, and consumer predation

Abstract

Predator-prey dynamics are widely used in ecology but seldom utilized in economics and marketing, despite their ability to express financial market agents' behaviors when considered in combination with economic cycles and financial crises. This multidisciplinary paper presents a stylized framework of a market cycle that combines the notions of supply and demand and predator-prey interactions between buyers and sellers of housing mortgages. We illustrate our framework using data from the Global Financial Crisis and a Lotka-Volterra predator-prey model. We find that with our framework we are able to capture the dynamics of the market, particularly the peak and decline in the number of sellers and sold subprime mortgages. Our framework sheds a new light on consumer behaviors, pinpointing how they can put themselves into vulnerable prey positions. This paper is one of the first of its kind to propose market phases and predator-prey dynamics nested in economic cycles and consumer buying trends.

Phase tipping: how cyclic ecosystems respond to contemporary climate

“…For example, the predator-prey paradigm is found across biological applications modelling, including epidemiology [80], pest control [81], fisheries [82], cancer [83,84] and agriculture [85,86]. The fundamental relationship described in predator-prey models also appears in many areas outside of the biological sciences, with recent examples including atmospheric sciences [87], economic development [64,65], trade and financial crises [88][89][90] and land management [91]. External disturbances of different kinds exist in all of these systems, suggesting that the P-tipping behaviours discovered in this paper are of broad practical relevance.…”

The Cyber-Industrialization of Catfishing and Romance Fraud

“…At the same time, we have provided ample evidence that their own relationship with the company is fraught with deception and exploitation. We would argue there are significant implications here for scholars studying labor rights and wage theft related to online work for example (see, Vallas & Schor, 2020;Bittle & Snider, 2018;and Stefano, 2016) with parallels to other industries where financial exploitation is common (e.g., predatory lending; see Lawson, 2013;Mesly et al, 2020).…”

Dark financial profile leading to debt traps – A theoretical framework

“…In this article, we examined the role of disconnection, irrationality and deception in the building of unsustainable debt by consumers of financial products and introduced the construct of the DFP. We debated how some overzealous consumers of financial products may lose track of their initial needs, goals and preferences and engage in a ‘wheel of misfortune’ (Mesly et al, 2020), that signifies mounting debt, leading to their demise. We ventured to state that DFP impedes the ability of consumers of financial products to make sound decisions with respect to their hierarchy of financial needs, goals and preferences: they can no longer decide which ones to prioritize given the stress imposed on them by indebtedness and deteriorating market conditions.…”