From research evidence to policy: mental health care in Viet Nam

Abstract

ProblemThe use of evidence-based policy is gaining attention in developing countries. Frameworks to analyse the process of developing policy and to assess whether evidence is likely to influence policy-makers are now available. However, the use of evidence in policies on caring for people with mental illness in developing countries has rarely been analysed. Approach This case study from Viet Nam illustrates how evidence can be used to influence policy. We summarize evidence on the burden of mental illness in Viet Nam and describe attempts to influence policy-makers. We also interviewed key stakeholders to ascertain their views on how policy could be affected. We then applied an analytical framework to the case study; this framework included an assessment of the political context in which the policy was developed, the links between organizations needed to influence policy, external influences on policy-makers and the nature of evidence required to influence policy-makers. Local setting The burden of mental illness among various population groups was large but there were few policies aimed at providing care for people with mental illness, apart from policies for providing hospital-based care for people with severe mental illness. Relevant changes The national plan proposes to incorporate screening for mental illness among women and children in order to implement early detection and treatment. Lessons learned Evidence on the burden of mental ill-health in Viet Nam is patchy and research in this area is still relatively undeveloped. Nonetheless the policy process was influenced by the evidence from research because key links between organizations and policy-makers were established at an early stage, the evidence was regarded as rigorous and the timing was opportune. Voir page 667 le résumé en français. En la página 667 figura un resumen en español.

The market for ‘evidence’ in policy processes: the case of child health policy in Andhra Pradesh, India and Viet Nam

“…Since this review there has (to the current authors' knowledge) only been one additional study in a developing country context. This piece was on mental health policy formation in Viet Nam by one of the authors here (Harpham and Tuan 2006).…”

Associations of Psychosocial Factors with Maternal Confidence Among Japanese and Vietnamese Mothers

“…In Vietnam, there is little published evidence about mental health problems in general (Harpham and Tuan 2006). Recent studies indicate that the prevalence of postpartum depression may be considerably high (33% among mothers of infants aged around 6 weeks) (Fisher et al 2004), and that poor maternal health is associated with poor child nutritional status (Harpham et al 2005).…”

Knowledge translation facilitating co-creation of evidence in public health

“…This has occurred as a natural conceptual development from the well-established evidence-based medicine movement 15 16. Increased focus on evidence-based public health (EBPH), defined as the development, implementation, and evaluation of effective policies and programmes in public health through application of principles of scientific reasoning, that is, use of research evidence,15 has numerous direct and indirect benefits 17. However, decisions are also influenced and must take into account factors other than research evidence.…”