From Public to Private Standards for Tropical Commodities: A Century of Global Discourse on Land Governance on the Forest Frontier

Abstract

Globalization and commodity exports have a long history in affecting land use changes and land rights on the tropical forest frontier. This paper reviews a century of social and environmental discourse around land issues for four commodities grown in the humid tropics-rubber, cocoa, oil palm and bananas. States have exercised sovereign rights over land and forest resources and the outcomes for deforestation and land rights of existing users have been quite varied depending on local institutional contexts and political economy. In the current period of globalization, as land use changes associated with tropical commodities have accelerated, land issues are now at center stage in the global discourse. However, efforts to protect forests and the rights of local communities and indigenous groups continue to be ad hoc and codification of minimum standards and their implementation remains a work in progress. Given a widespread failure of state directed policies and institutions to curb deforestation and protect land rights, the private sector, with the exception of the rubber industry, is emphasizing voluntary standards to certify sustainability of their products. This is an important step but expectations that they will effectively address concerns about the impact of tropical commodities expansion might be too high, given their voluntary nature, demand constraints, and the challenge of including smallholders. It is also doubtful that private standards can more than partially compensate for long standing weaknesses in land governance and institutions on the forest frontier. OPEN ACCESSForests 2015, 6 1302

Risk Assessment for Social Practices in Small Vegetable farms in Poland as a Tool for the Optimization of Quality Management Systems

“…The implementation of quality management systems, both at state and private level, is widely considered to be a factor that increases the profitability of farms, as well as a method for reducing the environmental effects associated with agricultural production. Bibliographic data presented by other researchers point to a relationship between the implementation of a quality management system and the amount of income [18,19]. Positive effects are perceived also in relation to the effectiveness of using natural resources in agricultural production.…”

Embedded Deforestation: The Case Study of the Brazilian–Italian Bovine Leather Trade

“…In this regard, a European Green Deal could serve as an important umbrella strategy to ensure coordination of the polices in different sectors that can potentially impact world forests [74]. Besides, the European Union Commission's Communication on Stepping up EU Action to Protect and Restore the World's Forests [41] is a good opportunity for common action that could lead to an EU-wide corporate due diligence mechanism to ensure legality and sustainability, instead of relying solely on voluntary commitments and private standards [75,76]. These efforts could enhance the effects of the policies aiming at reducing commodity-driven deforestation [77].…”

Fairtrade Impacts

“…Keywords: Fairtrade, informal, hired labour, value chains, sustainability there has been a rapid expansion of Voluntary Sustainability Standard (VSS) systems in agricultural commodity markets in recent years (Potts et al, 2014;Byerlee and Rueda, 2015). This expansion has affected increasing numbers of farming systems and rural societies, triggering significant critical analysis and discussion with regard to issues of governance (Tallontire et al, 2011) and their social, political, and economic impacts (e.g.…”