From metamorphosis to maturity in complex life cycles: equal performance of different juvenile life history pathways

Abstract

Performance in one stage of a complex life cycle may affect performance in the subsequent stage. Animals that start a new stage at a smaller size than conspecifics may either always remain smaller or they may be able to "catch up" through plasticity, usually elevated growth rates. We study how size at and date of metamorphosis affected subsequent performance in the terrestrial juvenile stage and lifetime fitness of spadefoot toads (Pelobates fuscus). We analyzed capture-recapture data of >3000 individuals sampled during nine years with mark-recapture models to estimate first-year juvenile survival probabilities and age-specific first-time breeding probabilities of toads, followed by model selection to assess whether these probabilities were correlated with size at and date of metamorphosis. Males attained maturity after two years, whereas females reached maturity 2-4 years after metamorphosis. Age at maturity was weakly correlated with metamorphic traits. In both sexes, first-year juvenile survival depended positively on date of metamorphosis and, in males, also negatively on size at metamorphosis. In males, toads that metamorphosed early at a small size had the highest probability to reach maturity. However, because very few toadlets metamorphosed early, the vast majority of male metamorphs had a very similar probability to reach maturity. A matrix projection model constructed for females showed that different juvenile life history pathways resulted in similar lifetime fitness. We found that the effects of date of and size at metamorphosis on different juvenile traits cancelled each other out such that toads that were small or large at metamorphosis had equal performance. Because the costs and benefits of juvenile life history pathways may also depend on population fluctuations, ample phenotypic variation in life history traits may be maintained. Abstract. Performance in one stage of a complex life cycle may affect performance in the subsequent stage. Animals that start a new stage at a smaller size than conspecifics may either always remain smaller or they may be able to ''catch up'' through plasticity, usually elevated growth rates. We study how size at and date of metamorphosis affected subsequent performance in the terrestrial juvenile stage and lifetime fitness of spadefoot toads (Pelobates fuscus). We analyzed capture-recapture data of .3000 individuals sampled during nine years with mark-recapture models to estimate first-year juvenile survival probabilities and agespecific first-time breeding probabilities of toads, followed by model selection to assess whether these probabilities were correlated with size at and date of metamorphosis. Males attained maturity after two years, whereas females reached maturity 2-4 years after metamorphosis. Age at maturity was weakly correlated with metamorphic traits. In both sexes, first-year juvenile survival depended positively on date of metamorphosis and, in males, also negatively on size at metamorphosis. In males, toads that metamorphosed early at a sma...

Slow life history and rapid extreme flood: demographic mechanisms and their consequences on population viability in a threatened amphibian

“…Our results indicate that survival differs between ontogenetic stages and that the survival rate increases with age. This is in accordance with previous studies suggesting that post‐metamorphosis survival is positively correlated with age and size in vertebrates (Stearns, ), and especially in amphibians (Altwegg & Reyer, ; Schmidt, Hödl & Schaub, ). In the latter, larger and older individuals outperform smaller and younger ones in osmoregulation and hydroregulation performance (Wells, ), which decreases mortality risks and the cost of biological functions such as dispersal.…”

Physiological, Behavioral and Maternal Factors That Contribute to Size Variation in Larval Amphibian Populations

“…Indeed, in vertebrates including amphibians catch-up growth is associated with permanently altered HPI axis activity and may be related to differing coping styles to extrinsic stressors [60], [64]. Another intrinsic factor that may be related to these hatching time, development and growth patterns is sex [65]. Studies of birds have found hatching to differ among the sexes and to potentially be an adaptive maternal effect [49]–[51].…”

Making leaps in amphibian ecotoxicology: translating individual‐level effects of contaminants to population viability

“…Thus, while larval life stages may be viable targets for remediation, preservation of sufficient high-quality adult habitat remains critical (Harper et al 2008) and additional experiments examining effects of contaminants on terrestrial adult amphibians are needed (Hopkins and Rowe 2010). Moreover, because reductions in body size are a common sublethal effect of contaminants (Boone and Bridges 2003) that may persist into terrestrial life stages (Todd et al 2012), future studies should rigorously evaluate size-specific survival of amphibians in field (e.g., Schmidt et al 2012). Finally, our study provides a habitat-based framework (Akcakaya 2000) for incorporating environmental stochasticity into models of population-level responses of amphibians to ecological or environmental stressors.…”