From Drought to Flood: A Water Balance Analysis of the Tuolumne River Basin during Extreme Conditions (2015 – 2017)

Abstract

The degree to which the hydrologic water balance in a snow-dominated headwater catchment is affected by annual climate variations is difficult to quantify, primarily due to uncertainties in measuring precipitation inputs and evapotranspiration (ET) losses. Over a recent three-year period, the snowpack in California's Sierra Nevada fluctuated from the lightest in recorded history (2015) to historically heaviest (2017), with a relatively average year in between (2016). This large dynamic range in climatic conditions presents a unique opportunity to investigate correlations between annual water availability and runoff in a snow-dominated catchment. Here, we estimate ET using a water balance approach where the water inputs to the system are spatially constrained using a combination of remote sensing, physically based modelling, and in-situ observations. For all 3 years of this study, the NASA Airborne Snow Observatory (ASO) combined periodic high-resolution snow depths from airborne Lidar with snow density estimates from an energy and mass balance model to produce spatial estimates of snow water equivalent over the Tuolumne headwater catchment at 50-m resolution. Using observed reservoir inflow at the basin outlet and the well-quantified snowmelt model results that benefit from periodic ASO snow depth updates, we estimate annual ET, runoff efficiency (RE), and the associated uncertainty across these three dissimilar water years. Throughout the study period, estimated annual ET magnitudes remained steady (222 mm in 2015, 151 mm in 2016, and 299 mm in 2017) relative to the large differences in basin input precipitation (547 mm in 2015, 1,060 mm in 2016, and 2,211 mm in 2017). These values compare well with independent satellite-derived ET estimates and previously published studies in this basin. Results reveal that ET in the Tuolumne does not scale linearly with the amount of available water to the basin, and that RE primarily depends on total annual snowfall proportion of precipitation. K E Y W O R D Sdata assimilation, evapotranspiration, headwater catchment hydrology, Lidar, snow modelling, spatial variability, water balance, water resources

Inferring Distributed Snow Depth by Leveraging Snow Pattern Repeatability: Investigation Using 47 Lidar Observations in the Tuolumne Watershed, Sierra Nevada, California

“…The seven water years covered by the library of ALS observations (WY2013 through WY2019) amazingly included (1) abnormally shallow WY2015 that was characterized by a snow volume return period (estimated average time between two seasons with similar snow volume) of over 600 years (Margulis, Cortés, Girotto, Huning, et al, 2016) and was among the shallowest historic snowpacks estimated from tree-ring SWE reconstruction (Belmecheri et al, 2016), and (2) abnormally deep WY2017 with the second-largest 1 April SWE ever recorded in this region (Hedrick et al, 2020). The library of observations allowed us to investigate how extreme years differed from snow distribution patterns from seasons with more typical snowpack.…”

Opportunities and Challenges Arising from Rapid Cryospheric Changes in the Southern Altai Mountains, China

“…Snowfall influences both flooding and drought due to its role in regulating the hydrological processes in snow-fed watersheds, with lower than normal winter snow accumulation resulting in a hydrological drought by reducing the water availability later in the hydrological year [80,81]. April-June water resources, which are supplied mainly by snowmelt, and annual water availability, are both positively correlated with the maximum snow thickness in the headwaters of the Irtysh River [33].…”

Mapping snow depth and volume at the alpine watershed scale from aerial imagery using Structure from Motion

“…The ability to fill missing information between point-based snow depth measurement locations has improved our understanding of large-scale snow processes. Data sets from airborne campaigns have been used to improve model capabilities to predict snow precipitation (Behrangi et al, 2018), observe snowfall distributions (Brandt et al, 2020), or improve snow energy balance models (Hedrick et al, 2020). Expanding the number of observed regions with spatially and temporally extensive records can further accelerate our ability to understand snow processes at scale.…”