From Comparison to Classification: A Cortical Tool for Boosting Perception

Abstract

Humans are much better in relative than in absolute judgments. This common assertion is based on findings that discrimination thresholds are much lower when measured with methods that allow interstimuli comparisons than when measured with methods that require classification of one stimulus at a time and are hence sensitive to memory load. We now challenged this notion by measuring discrimination thresholds and evoked potentials while listeners performed a two-tone frequency discrimination task. We tested various protocols that differed in the pattern of cross-trial tone repetition. We found that best performance was achieved only when listeners effectively used cross-trial repetition to avoid interstimulus comparisons with the repeated reference tone. Instead, they classified one tone, the nonreference tone, as either high or low by comparing it with a recently formed internal reference. Listeners were not aware of the switch from interstimulus comparison to classification. Its successful use was revealed by the conjunction of improved behavioral performance and an event-related potential component (P3), indicating an implicit perceptual decision, which followed the nonreference tone in each trial. Interestingly,tonerepetitionitselfdidnotsufficefortheswitch,implyingthatthebottlenecktodiscriminationdoesnotresideatthelower,sensorystage. Rather, the temporal consistency of repetition was important, suggesting the involvement of higher-level mechanisms with longer time constants. These findings suggest that classification is based on more automatic and accurate mechanisms than interstimulus comparisons and that the ability to effectively use them depends on a dynamic interplay between higher-and lower-level cortical mechanisms.

On the importance of anchoring and the consequences of its impairment in dyslexia

“…He attributed this effect to psychological or perceptual 'anchoring'. Recently, we have extended Harris's findings, showing the specific conditions under which listeners can anchor and that anchoring benefits may reach on order of magnitude reduction in discrimination thresholds (Nahum, Daikhin, Lubin, Cohen, & Ahissar, 2010).…”

Tactile perception and working memory in rats and humans

“…An advantage of the delayed comparison paradigm is that it allows a more accurate estimate of acuity. Thresholds in discriminating stimulus difference are lower in tasks where subjects compare two sequential stimuli than in tasks where they compare single stimuli to reference memory (13,14).…”

Effects of Literacy in Early Visual and Occipitotemporal Areas of Chinese and French Readers

“…It is therefore plausible that, with the acquisition of literacy in an alphabetic script, human V1 develops an improved encoding of letter shapes or letter fragments, which would at least partly account for the progressive increase in speed of reading in children (e.g., Grissemann, 1981;Lefavrais, 1967). There are several instances where expertise in a given faculty develops first in the high-order cortical areas, with expertise in earlier cortical areas following later on (e.g., Nahum, Daikhin, Lubin, Cohen, & Ahissar, 2010;Ahissar, Nahum, Nelken, & Hochstein, 2009).…”