From Caesarea to Athens: Greek Revival Edinburgh and the Question of Scottish Identity within the Unionist State

Abstract

In the early nineteenth century, the city of Edinburgh cultivated a reputation as "the Athens of the North." The paper explores the architectural aspects of this in relation to the city's sense of its own identity. It traces the idea of Edinburgh as a "modern Athens" back to the eighteenth century, when the connotations were cultural, intellectual, and topographical rather than architectural. With the emergence of the Greek revival, however, Edinburgh began actively to construct an image of classical Greece on the hilltops and in the streets of the expanding city. It is argued that the Athenian identity of Edinburgh should be viewed as the culmination of a series of developments dating back to the Act of Union between the Scottish and English Parliaments in 1707. As a result, Edinburgh lost its status as a capital city and struggled to reassert itself against the stronger economy of the south. Almost inevitably, the northern capital had to redefine itself in relation to London, the English and British capital. The major developments of Edinburgh in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, including the New Town and the urban proposals of Robert Adam, are interpreted in this light. As the eighteenth century progressed, the city grew more confident and by the early nineteenth century had settled upon its role within the Union and within the empire, which was that of cultural capital as a counterbalance to London, the political capital. The architectural culmination of the process of the redefinition of Edinburgh, however, coincided with the emergence of another mythology of Scottish identity, as seen through the Romantic vision of Sir Walter Scott. It implied a quite different, indigenous architecture that later found its expression in the Scots Baronial style. It is argued here, however, that duality does not contradict the idea of Edinburgh as Athens, nor, more generally, does it sit uneasily with the Scottish predilection for Greek architecture, but rather that it encapsulates the very essence of Scottish national identity: both proudly Scots and British.

Heritage Churches in the Niagara Region: An Essay on the Interpretation of Style

“…39 40 He also details a Doric entablature and capital from the Temple of Minerva, Athens. 41 St. Andrew's, Niagara-on-the-Lake, is the earliest example of Greek revival architecture in British North America and as such may be seen as vying with the grandest churches of the Anglican establishment, like St The Greek Doric order was most appropriate for a Scottish edifice in the new world given the promotion of Edinburgh as the "Athens of the North," 43 an epithet credited to Hugh William Williams [1773Williams [ -1829, an Edinburgh landscape painter nicknamed "Grecian" Williams, whose travels in Italy and Greece between 1816 and 1818 resulted in the publication of Travels in Italy, Greece and the Ionian Islands, in 1820. 44 In 1822 and 1826, he exhibited watercolours from his travels, and another illustrated publication, Select Views in Greece, appeared in 1829.…”

Kαλoι κ'αγαθoι (The Beautiful and the Good): Classical School Architecture and Educational Elitism in Early Nineteenth-Century Edinburgh

“…m Hamilton's Greek Revival set-piece at the base of Edinburgh's Calton Hill contributed to the powerful idea of Edinburgh as Athens of the British Empire, compared to London's Rome. 112 Internally, the school was intended to provide rooms for five masters (including the rector), but, as built, provided six large classrooms, a rector's suite, and a number of smaller classrooms. Access between each section (central hall, linking blocks and flanking wings) was originally provided not by corridors, but directly through classrooms, small irregular anterooms, and in the linking blocks and wings by stairwells to the lower level.…”

La transformation de l’ancienne Royal High School à Édimbourg, un projet controversé

“…»(Griscom, 1824, p. 223; Barclay, 1974, p. 16) 10 La transformation de l'ancienne Royal High School à Édimbourg, un projet cont... prendre : arc de triomphe, panthéon ou parthénon. L'idée qu'Édimbourg serait une sorte d'Athènes du Nord moderne germe au cours de ce débat des années1817 -1819(Lowrey, 2001.Le peintre Hugh William Williams (1773-1829, au retour de son voyage en Grèce, est l'un des premiers à établir un parallèle entre Édimbourg et Athènes23 . Le révérend Archibald Alison, membre du comité en charge de la construction du National Monument, insiste sur la nécessité pour l'Écosse de disposer de son propre monument afin de pouvoir affirmer sa place au sein de l'Empire britannique24 .…”