From board to bedside – training the communication competences of medical students with role plays

Abstract

BackgroundRole plays and standardized patients are often used in medical education and have proven to be effective tools for enhancing the communication skills of medical students. Most course concepts need additional time and teaching staff, and there are only a few studies about role plays in the preclinical segment.MethodsWe developed a highly consolidated concept for the curricular course of 2nd-year medical students, including ten role plays about five subjects: anamnesis, shared decision making, prevention, breaking bad news, and so-called “difficult interactions”. Before the course, all students were asked about their expectations and attitudes toward the course. After the course, all students rated the course, their individual learning progress, whether their expectations had been fulfilled, and re-evaluated their attitudes. Questionnaires were self-report measures and had a quantitative and a short qualitative section and were analyzed with descriptive statistics. Group differences (sex, age, role played) were evaluated with t tests at a Bonferonni-corrected significance level of p = .03 and the non-parametric U-tests.ResultsImplementing this practical course concept is possible without incurring additional costs. This paper not only shows how that can be done but also provides 5 examples of role scripts for different training subjects. The course concept was highly appreciated by the students. More than 75% felt that they had learned important communication techniques and would be better able to handle difficult situations. Playing the doctor’s role was felt to be more useful than playing the patient’s role. Women admitted a higher degree of shyness in the beginning and gave higher ratings to their learning progress than men. Students’ most frequent wish in the qualitative analysis was to be able to play the doctor’s role at least once. The students’ answers showed a differentiated pattern, thus suggesting that the influence of social desirability was minimal.ConclusionsPractical skills can be taught successfully in the preclinical stage of medical education even without an increase in resources. The course concept described in this article provides an effective means by which to do so.

Transition in pharmacology: From theoretical knowledge of medicines to practice-oriented approach. Do role-plays help?

“…Numerous studies conducted in medical students have demonstrated the effectiveness of role-play in teaching technical and communication skills in medical education. 6,7,10,11 In our study, we used the peer-role play technique that involved all the students to perform, learn and to personally experience patient concerns in front of their peers. Continuous feedback from peers gave the students an opportunity to sharpen their communication skills in a safe and supportive classroom environment.…”

Teaching Communication Skills and Decision-Making to University Students

“…This training module is designed both for individual and group study (Bishop et al, 2016). Possible ways for standardization of teaching communicative skills, assessment of certain communication factors before and after the courses of study, their integration into educational programs are proposed (Drdla & Loffler-Stastka, 2016;Kölfen, 2016;Modi et al, 2016;McKenzie, 2016;Cämmerer, Martin & Rockenbauch, 2016;Turner et al, 2016;Luttenberger et al, 2014;Mole, 2016;Hess et al, 2016).…”

Toma de decisiones compartidas en la atención de pacientes con diabetes mellitus: un desafío para Latinoamérica

“…El desarrollo de políticas que mejoren la oferta de servicios y proteja la duración de la consulta ayudaría a aliviar, al menos en parte, uno de los inconvenientes que impide a los médicos implementar la TDC 35 . Resulta, además, fundamental el desarrollo de políticas que promuevan la incorporación de la enseñanza de destrezas comunicacionales, habilidades propias de TDC y atención centrada en el paciente, en las mallas curriculares de las escuelas de medicina, a modo de incorporar estos conocimientos de manera temprana y persistente en el entrenamiento de clínicos [34][35][36][37] . Recientemente, en 2015, la Asociación Americana de Diabetes (ADA) y la Asociación Europea para el Estudio de la Diabetes (EASD) reconocieron que la atención centrada en el paciente (y no en la enfermedad) es la forma de atención que mejor aborda la complejidad de enfrentarse a un paciente y su individualidad.…”