From aggressively formalised to intensely in/formalised: accounting for a wider range of videogame development practices

Abstract

Beyond the dominant North American and Japanese console manufacturers and multinational publishers, the global videogame industry is fragmenting. New audiences, distribution platforms, and development tools are expanding the videogame industry into an ecosystem that is at once broadly global and intensely localised. Taking advantage of this nebulous environment are increasingly visible fringes of hobbyists, amateurs, students, and artists that are pushing videogame development in new directions in terms of aesthetics, design process, and distribution channels. The activities of these fringe creators represent a critical but undertheorised aspect of the videogame industry. This article builds on Lobato and Thomas's notion of 'informal media economies' to suggest that the work of these fringes can be usefully considered as informal videogame development practices. It provides a historical look at the videogame industry that demonstrates how it transitioned from a period of aggressive formalisation through the 1980s to the early 2000s into a more intense intermingling of formal and informal actors and processes in the early 2010s. In doing so, this article traces the shifting conduits of creative practice, commerce, and power that these emerging informal practices represent so as to more fully account for the contemporary global videogame industry.

The Cultural Field of Video Game Production in Australia

“…[they] are not stars, nor are they rich or even particularly successful-in fact, the majority of cultural workers toil in relatively anonymous enterprises, either living off the erratic incomes from 'projects' or more conventionally on low or subsistence-level wages. (Banks, 2007, p. 10) Yet in the cultural industry of videogames, decades of "aggressive formalization" (Keogh, 2019) mean that the largest corporations and most successful "indie" millionaires cast a long shadow that obscures a much broader field of cultural activity and struggle. As artist-gamemaker Robert Yang (2017) notes, "game dev culture has a specific idea of success that involves astronomical blockbuster commercial success, and most of us will always fall way short of it, in ways that often feel out of our control."…”

App Imperialism: The Political Economy of the Canadian App Store

“…On a global level, console gaming has been, and still is, only accessible to a small percentage of affluent consumers. This relative inaccessibility, in turn, did little to break down the "cultural bottlenecks" associated with the exclusionary communities of game enthusiasts surrounding console and PC gaming platforms (Keogh, 2019).…”

Apps of Empire: Global Capitalism and the App Economy

“…Today, the practice of modding has morphed into something else, as it is largely replaced by other, more diverse game-making practices and cultures that include “everyday gamemakers” (Young, 2018) alongside the “aggressively formalized” practices of publisher-funded studios (Keogh, 2019). Yet, despite the affordability and accessibility of a new generation of game development tools that propel this burgeoning ecosystem forward, these contemporary creative practices signal a continuation of modding rather than a radical break.…”