Freshwater and marine migration and survival of endangered Cultus Lake sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) smolts using POST, a large-scale acoustic telemetry array
Abstract:Freshwater and early marine migration and survival of endangered Cultus Lake sockeye ( Oncorhynchus nerka ) salmon were studied using the Pacific Ocean Shelf Tracking (POST) array. Smolts were acoustically tagged in 2004–2007, and their migration was recorded within the lower Fraser River and coastal southern British Columbia waters. Most smolts showed rapid directional movement (swimming speeds of ~15–30 km·day–1). Average exit time from the Fraser River was 4.0–5.6 days after release, and average residence t… Show more
“…The smolts were implanted with specially programmed tags that transmitted during both the outbound smolt and subsequent 2009 inbound adult migration phases, with an intervening 25-mo quiet period to conserve battery power (49). Although the 2007 smolts experienced 28% survival after migrating downriver and out of the Salish Sea (which was equal to or higher than the survival in the previous 3 y) (44), only 1% of the released smolts (two of 200) returned as adults, consistent with the smolt-toadult survival of both the untagged Cultus Lake hatchery smolts (0.5%) and wild-origin smolts (1.4%) (49). Both adults were detected returning to BC within 1 d of each other via the JDF Strait in 2009, even though they had emigrated via QCS as smolts in 2007 1 wk apart (Movies S2 and S3).…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 68%
“…The median survival of the steelhead and sockeye populations estimated in this study was 16.5% (i.e., one in six juveniles surviving to exit from the Salish Sea), with population-specific marine travel times as long as 28 d depending on the distance traveled. In contrast, survival over the entire juvenile-to-adult lifespan of many Salish Sea salmon populations has decreased to only 1% to 4% in the past two decades (28,(41)(42)(43)(44)(45), with concerns raised about the relative role of salmon aquaculture, hatcheries, climate change, and ecosystem changes in causing the decline (46)(47)(48). Our measurements of survival within the first weeks of the migration (i.e., one of six smolts surviving) can thus be compared with total survival over the period of approximately 2.5 y until adult return generated by other methods (approximately one in 25-100 of outmigrating juveniles); the implication is that the cumulative total mortality beyond the Salish Sea is approximately four to 17 times larger than what is experienced within the geographic limits of the Salish Sea array in roughly the first month of life in the sea, making it unlikely that year-class strength is primarily determined very early in the marine life history.…”
Many salmon populations in both the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans have experienced sharply decreasing returns and high ocean mortality in the past two decades, with some populations facing extirpation if current marine survival trends continue. Our inability to monitor the movements of marine fish or to directly measure their survival precludes experimental tests of theories concerning the factors regulating fish populations, and thus limits scientific advance in many aspects of fisheries management and conservation. Here we report a large-scale synthesis of survival and movement rates of free-ranging juvenile salmon across four species, 13 river watersheds, and 44 release groups of salmon smolts (>3,500 fish tagged in total) in rivers and coastal ocean waters, including an assessment of where mortality predominantly occurs during the juvenile migration. Of particular importance, our data indicate that, over the size range of smolts tagged, (i) smolt survival was not strongly related to size at release, (ii) tag burden did not appear to strongly reduce the survival of smaller animals, and (iii) for at least some populations, substantial mortality occurred much later in the migration and more distant from the river of origin than generally expected. Our findings thus have implications for determining where effort should be invested to improve the accuracy of salmon forecasting, to understand the mechanisms driving salmon declines, and to predict the impact of climate change on salmon stocks.
“…The smolts were implanted with specially programmed tags that transmitted during both the outbound smolt and subsequent 2009 inbound adult migration phases, with an intervening 25-mo quiet period to conserve battery power (49). Although the 2007 smolts experienced 28% survival after migrating downriver and out of the Salish Sea (which was equal to or higher than the survival in the previous 3 y) (44), only 1% of the released smolts (two of 200) returned as adults, consistent with the smolt-toadult survival of both the untagged Cultus Lake hatchery smolts (0.5%) and wild-origin smolts (1.4%) (49). Both adults were detected returning to BC within 1 d of each other via the JDF Strait in 2009, even though they had emigrated via QCS as smolts in 2007 1 wk apart (Movies S2 and S3).…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 68%
“…The median survival of the steelhead and sockeye populations estimated in this study was 16.5% (i.e., one in six juveniles surviving to exit from the Salish Sea), with population-specific marine travel times as long as 28 d depending on the distance traveled. In contrast, survival over the entire juvenile-to-adult lifespan of many Salish Sea salmon populations has decreased to only 1% to 4% in the past two decades (28,(41)(42)(43)(44)(45), with concerns raised about the relative role of salmon aquaculture, hatcheries, climate change, and ecosystem changes in causing the decline (46)(47)(48). Our measurements of survival within the first weeks of the migration (i.e., one of six smolts surviving) can thus be compared with total survival over the period of approximately 2.5 y until adult return generated by other methods (approximately one in 25-100 of outmigrating juveniles); the implication is that the cumulative total mortality beyond the Salish Sea is approximately four to 17 times larger than what is experienced within the geographic limits of the Salish Sea array in roughly the first month of life in the sea, making it unlikely that year-class strength is primarily determined very early in the marine life history.…”
Many salmon populations in both the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans have experienced sharply decreasing returns and high ocean mortality in the past two decades, with some populations facing extirpation if current marine survival trends continue. Our inability to monitor the movements of marine fish or to directly measure their survival precludes experimental tests of theories concerning the factors regulating fish populations, and thus limits scientific advance in many aspects of fisheries management and conservation. Here we report a large-scale synthesis of survival and movement rates of free-ranging juvenile salmon across four species, 13 river watersheds, and 44 release groups of salmon smolts (>3,500 fish tagged in total) in rivers and coastal ocean waters, including an assessment of where mortality predominantly occurs during the juvenile migration. Of particular importance, our data indicate that, over the size range of smolts tagged, (i) smolt survival was not strongly related to size at release, (ii) tag burden did not appear to strongly reduce the survival of smaller animals, and (iii) for at least some populations, substantial mortality occurred much later in the migration and more distant from the river of origin than generally expected. Our findings thus have implications for determining where effort should be invested to improve the accuracy of salmon forecasting, to understand the mechanisms driving salmon declines, and to predict the impact of climate change on salmon stocks.
“…Using acoustic telemetry tags and infrastructure to track small fish (e.g., Welch et al 2002, 2009, Cooke et al 2011a), the present research program was conducted to provide the first insight into the movements and survival of wild sockeye salmon smolts during their migration from natal rearing grounds to the open ocean. The Chilko Lake population was selected for the study (Fig.…”
Abstract. Few estimates of migration rates or descriptions of behavior or survival exist for wild populations of out-migrating Pacific salmon smolts from natal freshwater rearing areas to the ocean. Using acoustic transmitters and fixed receiver arrays across four years (2010-2013), we tracked the migration of >1850 wild sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) smolts from Chilko Lake, British Columbia, to the coastal Pacific Ocean (>1000 km distance). Cumulative survival to the ocean ranged 3-10% among years, although this may be slightly underestimated due to technical limitations at the final receiver array. Distinct spatial patterns in both behavior and survival were observed through all years. In small, clear, upper-river reaches, downstream migration largely occurred at night at speeds up to 50 km/d and coincided with poor survival. Among years, only 57-78% of smolts survived the first 80 km. Parallel laboratory experiments revealed excellent short-term survival and unhindered swimming performance of dummy-tagged smolts, suggesting that predators rather than tagging effects were responsible for the initial high mortality of acoustic-tagged smolts. Migration speeds increased in the Fraser River mainstem (~220 km/d in some years), diel movement patterns ceased, and smolt survival generally exceeded 90% in this segment. Marine movement rates and survival were variable across years, with among-year segment-specific survival being the most variable and lowest (19-61%) during the final (and longest, 240 km) marine migration segment. Osmoregulatory preparedness was not expected to influence marine survival, as smolts could maintain normal levels of plasma chloride when experimentally exposed to saltwater (30 ppt) immediately upon commencing their migration from Chilko Lake. Transportation of smolts downstream generally increased survival to the farthest marine array. The act of tagging may have affected smolts in the marine environment in some years as dummy-tagged fish had poorer survival than control fish when transitioned to saltwater in laboratory-based experiments. Current fisheries models for forecasting the number of adult sockeye returning to spawn have been inaccurate in recent years and generally do not incorporate juvenile or smolt survival information. Our results highlight significant potential for early migration conditions to influence adult recruitment.
“…To understand behaviors employed or stimuli used by migrating fish, movement dynamics must be estimated with fairly high precision (e.g., hourly or daily). However, many estimates of fish movement rely solely on net distance and speed between capture/release and recapture locations, assuming a straight-line trajectory (Thorstad et al 2007, Welch et al 2009, Welch et al 2011, Tomaro et al 2012. While such information is useful for characterizing spatial distributions, it cannot resolve the ecological and behavioral processes involved in a fish moving between two locations.…”
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.