Frequency drift in MR spectroscopy at 3T

Abstract

Purpose Heating of gradient coils and passive shim components is a common cause of instability in the B 0 field, especially when gradient intensive sequences are used. The aim of the study was to set a benchmark for typical drift encountered during MR spectroscopy (MRS) to assess the need for real-time field-frequency locking on MRI scanners by comparing field drift data from a large number of sites. Method A standardized protocol was developed for 80 participating sites using 99 3T MR scanners from 3 major vendors. Phantom water signals were acquired before and after an EPI sequence. The protocol consisted of: minimal preparatory imaging; a short pre-fMRI PRESS; a ten-minute fMRI acquisition; and a long post-fMRI PRESS acquisition. Both pre- and post-fMRI PRESS were non-water suppressed. Real-time frequency stabilization/adjustment was switched off when appropriate. Sixty scanners repeated the protocol for a second dataset. In addition, a three-hour post-fMRI MRS acquisition was performed at one site to observe change of gradient temperature and drift rate. Spectral analysis was performed using MATLAB. Frequency drift in pre-fMRI PRESS data were compared with the first 5:20 minutes and the full 30:00 minutes of data after fMRI. Median (interquartile range) drifts were measured and showed in violin plot. Paired t-tests were performed to compare frequency drift pre- and post-fMRI. A simulated in vivo spectrum was generated using FID-A to visualize the effect of the observed frequency drifts. The simulated spectrum was convolved with the frequency trace for the most extreme cases. Impacts of frequency drifts on NAA and GABA were also simulated as a function of linear drift. Data from the repeated protocol were compared with the corresponding first dataset using Pearson's and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). Results Of the data collected from 99 scanners, 4 were excluded due to various reasons. Thus, data from 95 scanners were ultimately analyzed. For the first 5:20 min (64 transients), median (interquartile range) drift was 0.44 (1.29) Hz before fMRI and 0.83 (1.29) Hz after. This increased to 3.15 (4.02) Hz for the full 30 min (360 transients) run. Average drift rates were 0.29 Hz/min before fMRI and 0.43 Hz/min after. Paired t-tests indicated that drift increased after fMRI, as expected (p < 0.05). Simulated spectra convolved with the frequency drift showed that the intensity of the NAA singlet was reduced by up to 26%, 44 % and 18% for GE, Philips and Siemens scanners after fMRI, respectively. ICCs indicated good agreement between datasets acquired on separate days. The single site long acquisition showed drift rate was reduced to 0.03 Hz/min approximately three hours after fMRI. Discussion This study analyzed frequency drift data from 95 3T MRI scanners. Median levels of drift were relatively low (5-min average under 1 Hz), but the most extreme cases suffered from higher ...

Comparison of linear combination modeling strategies for edited magnetic resonance spectroscopy at 3 T

“…A lower variance does not, of course, necessarily reflect greater modeling accuracy, but under the assumption that the homogeneous study population and data acquisition contribute comparably little biological and instrumental variance, CVs will predominantly reflect variance introduced by the modeling approach. Recently, the field has witnessed increasing efforts to generate simulated spectra with known ground truth as a gold standard, although these approaches can only be successful to the extent that those spectra are truly representative of in vivo data 41–43 . Further, such gold standard studies with a known ground truth could be used to validate whether a correct separation of GABA and MM 3co is achievable by advanced LCM.…”

“…Recently, the field has witnessed increasing efforts to generate simulated spectra with known ground truth as a gold standard, although these approaches can only be successful to the extent that those spectra are truly representative of in vivo data. [41][42][43] Further, such gold standard studies with a known ground truth could be used to validate whether a correct separation of GABA and MM 3co is achievable by advanced LCM. This study indicates a low-to-moderate correlation between the GABA and MM 3co estimates, suggesting that the two components are not reliably separated.…”

Improving reproducibility of proton MRS brain thermometry: theoretical and empirical approaches

“…(1) We focused on improving the reproducibility or reducing random errors of the 1 H MRS-based thermometry by optimally combining temperatures measured from three references. In 1 H MRS-based thermometry, systematic errors or consistent biases may result from several methodological aspects of the measurement such as gradient heating, 29,30 separate measurement of water and reference signals, 30 errors in the calibration parameters, 25,31 etc. For example, the range of frequency shift of the water suppressed spectrum may be from 0 to 9 Hz in 13 minutes with respect to the separately measured non-water suppressed spectrum, corresponding temperature errors from 0 to -3.0 o C. 30 The present work was not dedicated to improving the accuracy or reducing the systematic errors.…”

Comparison of linear combination modeling strategies for GABA-edited MRS at 3T

“…A lower variance does, of course, not necessarily reflect greater modeling accuracy, but under the assumption that the homogeneous study population and data acquisition contribute comparably little biological and instrumental variance, CVs will predominantly reflect variance introduced by the modeling approach. Recently, the field is witnessing increasing efforts to generate simulated spectra with known ground truth as a gold standard, although these approaches can only be successful to the extent that those spectra are truly representative of in-vivo data [41][42][43] . Further, such gold standard studies with a known ground truth could be used to validate whether a correct separation of GABA and MM 3co is achievable by advanced LCM.…”