Freelance Workers and Contract Uncertainty: The Effects of Contractual Changes in the Television Industry

Abstract

Changes in the competitive and regulative conditions of British television over the 1980s and 1990s make for an environment of increased uncertainty for those who work in television. Broadcasting legislation, increased competition and technological advances have changed the working practices of the UK's 28,000 production workforce. The introduction of a 25 per cent quota of independent productions on all terrestrial channels, the implementation of Producer Choice in the BBC and the creation of a Network Centre in ITV, leading to a new commissioning process along with merger rationalisation and increasing competition have all contributed to constructing a workforce in which over 50 per cent are freelance and face much uncertainty. This paper focuses on some of the ways workers have experienced and responded to these changes by analysing the postal questionnaire and diary-data collected in an eight-wave panel study of 436 creative production workers in British television 1994-97, collected by the British Film Institute. This paper considers whether uncertainty is a problem and finds that it is for the majority of these workers. The question of what makes uncertainty a problem is also considered. Individuals were found to cope with uncertainty by diversifying the income sources, by collecting information, building informal networks and by thinking of leaving work in television.

Artists and Multiple Job Holding—Breadwinning Work as Mediating Between Bohemian and Entrepreneurial Identities and Behavior

“…Due to the results of this study pointing to the interrelation between different kinds of work, I argue that this is an issue worthy of attention as much as any exploitative characteristic of creative work explored by researchers, such as Dex et al (2000), Gill (2014), Eikhof and Warhurst (2013), and Siebert and Wilson (2013).…”

Careering alone: Careers and social capital in the financial services and television industries

“…The proportion of the total production workforce that are freelance in the UK increased from 39 percent in 1989 to 60 percent in 1996 (Skillset, 1996a). Some freelancers have spent their whole careers as freelancers, but many others have become freelance as the result of restructuring in the large producer-broadcasters that began in the 1980s (Dex et al, 1998;McKinlay & Quinn, 1998). As well as seeking numerical flexibility, firms are seeking functional flexibility through greater use of multiskilled media or craft workers.…”

Hierarchical Forms of Outsourcing and the Creation of Dependency

“…For the UK, Harvey (2003) shows that the deregulation in the industry has led to a strong increase in hierarchical forms of outsourcing. Similar arguments are put forward in Dex et al (2000) for the British media industry and Muehlberger (2004) for the Austrian insurance industry. Grimshaw and Rubery (2005) argue that hierarchical outsourcing has also an effect on internal labour because it decreases the bargaining power of employed labour and circumvents institutionalized hierarchical structures.…”