Framework for Detailed Comparison of Building Environmental Assessment Tools

Abstract

Understanding how Building Environmental Assessments Tools (BEATs) measure and define "environmental" building is of great interest to many stakeholders, but it is difficult to understand how BEATs relate to each other, as well as to make detailed and systematic tool comparisons. A framework for comparing BEATs is presented in the following which facilitates an understanding and comparison of similarities and differences in terms of structure, content, aggregation, and scope. The framework was tested by comparing three distinctly different assessment tools; LEED-NC v3, Code for Sustainable Homes (CSH), and EcoEffect. Illustrations of the hierarchical structure of the tools gave a clear overview of their structural differences. When using the framework, the analysis showed that all three tools treat issues related to the main assessment categories: Energy and Pollution, Indoor Environment, and Materials and Waste. However, the environmental issues addressed, and the parameters defining the object of study, differ and, subsequently, so do rating, results, categories, issues, input data, aggregation methodology, and weighting. This means that BEATs measure "environmental" building differently and push "environmental" design in different directions. Therefore, tool comparisons are important, and the framework can be used to make these comparisons in a more detailed and systematic way.

Gender Differences in Environmental Perspectives among Urban Design Professionals

“…The environmental aspects were chosen based on the content of the environmental assessment tools LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) for neighborhood development [41], BREEAM (BRE Environmental Assessment Method) Community [42] and CASBEE (Comprehensive Assessment System for Built Environment Efficiency) for Urban Development [43]. In addition, the ecosystem services and toxic materials were included as they are important environmental aspects [44]. Questions regarding the knowledge and use of neighborhood and building environmental tools and environmental management systems and ecological world views were also included.…”

Methodology for environmental assessment in Antarctic buildings

“…It is worth mentioning that the assessment tools are composed of categories, criteria, and indicators that seek to align with the issues inherent to the global concept of sustainability, respecting the local characteristics (Mateus and Bragança, 2011). However, there is no consensus in the meaning of the nomenclatures used in the several assessment methods and tools (Wallhagen et al, 2013). So, for the present work, the meanings are adopted according to the ones presented in Table 1.…”

Taking Lead for Sustainability: Environmental Managers as Institutional Entrepreneurs

“…This included arranging specific "environmental days" for all employees, where invited environmental champions and/or decision-makers gave plenary speeches, and where, for example, Al Gore's movie "An Inconvenient Truth", released in 2006, was shown. Although the movie focuses on climate change, it was the energy aspect that took root within the Swedish AEC industry, specifically in the operational use of buildings [49]. In addition, new demands on national building energy standards arrived [50,51].…”