Forward-looking financial risk management and the housing market in the United Kingdom: is there a role for sentiment indicators?

Abstract

Purpose In the current low-interest market environment, more and more asset managers have started to consider to invest in property markets. To implement adequate and forward-looking risk management procedures, this market should be analyzed in more detail. Therefore, this study aims to examine the housing market data from the UK. More specifically, sentiment data and house prices are examined, using techniques of time-series econometrics suggested by Toda and Yamamoto (1995). The monthly data used in this study is the RICS Housing Market Survey and the Nationwide House Price Index – covering the period from January 2000 to December 2018. Furthermore, the authors also analyze the stability of the implemented Granger causality tests. In sum, the authors found clear empirical evidence for unidirectional Granger causality from sentiment indicator to the house prices index. Consequently, the sentiment indicator can help to forecast property prices in the UK. Design/methodology/approach By investigating sentiment data for house prices using techniques of time-series econometrics (more specifically the procedure suggested by Toda and Yamamoto, 1995), the research question whether sentiment indicators can be helpful to predict property prices in the UK is analyzed empirically. Findings The empirical results show that the RICS Housing Market Survey can help to predict the house prices in the UK. Practical implications Given these findings, the information provided by property market sentiment indicators certainly should be used in a forward-looking early warning system for house prices in the UK. Originality/value To authors’ knowledge, this is the first paper that uses the procedure suggested by Toda and Yamaoto to search for suitable early warning indicators for investors in UK real estate assets.

Risk premia and the European government bond market: new empirical evidence and some thoughts from the perspective of the life insurance industry

“…Moreover, Kunze et al. ( 2020 ) have employed this approach to search for a useful leading indicator of house prices in the United Kingdom. This popularity most probably is a result of the favorable Monte Carlo evidence that has been presented by Zapata and Rambaldi ( 1997 ).…”

Peer-to-peer lending platform risk analysis: an early warning model based on multi-dimensional information

“…For this problem, McShane (2018) stressed the importance of proactive risk management processes. Through the research of Rodriguez Gonzalez et al (2018), Kunze et al (2020), andRodriguez Gonzalez et al (2021) on the real estate market, they pointed out that the establishment of early warning indicator systems is of great significance for proactive risk management processes. Vazquez and Federico (2015) have stressed the ability to resist systemic risk is an important factor in measuring the operating status of the platform.…”

“…Through the research of Rodriguez Gonzalez et al. (2018), Kunze et al. (2020), and Rodriguez Gonzalez et al.…”

Leading indicators for US house prices: New evidence and implications for EU financial risk managers

“…McLaren and Shanbhogue (2011) have shown that the combination of the RICS data with Internet search data (more specifically, people interested in both buying and selling properties) can be helpful to forecast house prices. Moreover, Kunze et al (2020), meanwhile, have reported quite favourable empirical evidence testing for Granger causality between the RICS survey data and the level of house prices in the United Kingdom. Doing so they also have employed the approach that has been suggested by Toda and Yamamoto (1995).…”

“…Doing so they also have employed the approach that has been suggested by Toda and Yamamoto (1995). Therefore, Kunze et al (2020)—which also builds on Rodriguez Gonzalez et al (2018)—is of some importance for the empirical evidence to be presented later on.…”