Formulary availability and regulatory barriers to accessibility of opioids for cancer pain in Asia: a report from the Global Opioid Policy Initiative (GOPI)
Abstract:Asia is a heterogeneous region with substantial variability in economic, social and palliative care development. While the global consumption of opioids has increased, the consumption in most Asian countries has not increased at the same rate. This is the first comprehensive study of opioid availability and accessibility for cancer patients in Asia. Data are reported on the availability and accessibility of opioids for the management of cancer pain in 20 of 28 countries. The countries in the report represent 2… Show more
“…[4849505152] Progress has been made to improve opioid availability within India, but many patients with cancer still suffer in avoidable pain. [535455] For example, the palliative care department at SICH has made significant effort to procure morphine and make the medication available to patients, especially those seen in the palliative care department.…”
Context:Nurses in India often practice in resource-constrained settings and care for cancer patients with high symptom burden yet receive little oncology or palliative care training.Aim:The aim of this study is to explore challenges encountered by nurses in India and offer recommendations to improve the delivery of oncology and palliative care.Methods:Qualitative ethnography.Setting:The study was conducted at a government cancer hospital in urban South India.Sample:Thirty-seven oncology/palliative care nurses and 22 others (physicians, social workers, pharmacists, patients/family members) who interact closely with nurses were included in the study.Data Collection:Data were collected over 9 months (September 2011â June 2012). Key data sources included over 400 hours of participant observation and 54 audio-recorded semi-structured interviews.Analysis:Systematic qualitative analysis of field notes and interview transcripts identified key themes and patterns.Results:Key concerns of nurses included safety related to chemotherapy administration, workload and clerical responsibilities, patients who died on the wards, monitoring family attendants, and lack of supplies. Many participants verbalized distress that they received no formal oncology training.Conclusions:Recommendations to support nurses in India include: prioritize safety, optimize role of the nurse and explore innovative models of care delivery, empower staff nurses, strengthen nurse leadership, offer relevant educational programs, enhance teamwork, improve cancer pain management, and engage in research and quality improvement projects. Strong institutional commitment and leadership are required to implement interventions to support nurses. Successful interventions must account for existing cultural and professional norms and first address safety needs of nurses. Positive aspects from existing models of care delivery can be adapted and integrated into general nursing practice.
“…[4849505152] Progress has been made to improve opioid availability within India, but many patients with cancer still suffer in avoidable pain. [535455] For example, the palliative care department at SICH has made significant effort to procure morphine and make the medication available to patients, especially those seen in the palliative care department.…”
Context:Nurses in India often practice in resource-constrained settings and care for cancer patients with high symptom burden yet receive little oncology or palliative care training.Aim:The aim of this study is to explore challenges encountered by nurses in India and offer recommendations to improve the delivery of oncology and palliative care.Methods:Qualitative ethnography.Setting:The study was conducted at a government cancer hospital in urban South India.Sample:Thirty-seven oncology/palliative care nurses and 22 others (physicians, social workers, pharmacists, patients/family members) who interact closely with nurses were included in the study.Data Collection:Data were collected over 9 months (September 2011â June 2012). Key data sources included over 400 hours of participant observation and 54 audio-recorded semi-structured interviews.Analysis:Systematic qualitative analysis of field notes and interview transcripts identified key themes and patterns.Results:Key concerns of nurses included safety related to chemotherapy administration, workload and clerical responsibilities, patients who died on the wards, monitoring family attendants, and lack of supplies. Many participants verbalized distress that they received no formal oncology training.Conclusions:Recommendations to support nurses in India include: prioritize safety, optimize role of the nurse and explore innovative models of care delivery, empower staff nurses, strengthen nurse leadership, offer relevant educational programs, enhance teamwork, improve cancer pain management, and engage in research and quality improvement projects. Strong institutional commitment and leadership are required to implement interventions to support nurses. Successful interventions must account for existing cultural and professional norms and first address safety needs of nurses. Positive aspects from existing models of care delivery can be adapted and integrated into general nursing practice.
“…19 Although opioids are generally available and concerns about undertreatment of pain exist, alternative approaches and tools for the treatment of chronic pain are emphasized, with substantially lower quantities of opioids prescribed. [46][47][48] Overall, medical system culture -including less commercialization in health care and less influence from the pharmaceutical industry and advertising -has been found to play a role in differentiating levels of opioid use in different contexts: some practices rely less on pharmacotherapy to deal with pain. 49,50 Consequently, opioid-related harms as observed in North America are considered uncommon elsewhere (e.g., in Europe).…”
Analysis⢠Canada has been facing a major public health crisis of prescription opioidârelated morbidity and deaths.⢠Several -largely narrow and reactive in scope -interventions have been implemented since 2010, yet, they have remained ineffective in curtailing morbidity and deaths.⢠Overall amounts and patterns (e.g., high dose) of prescription opioids dispensed are primary causal drivers of population-level morbidity and mortality.⢠Authorities should urgently implement effective (e.g., enforceable guidelines with use/dose restrictions) evidence-based measures to reduce overall amounts of opioid dispensing and thus harms.
“…A significant barrier to more effective pain relief continues to be a reluctance or concern to prescribe opioid analgesics. In many parts of the world, opioid use is virtually nonexistent, even for the treatment of severe to very severe pain at end of life [13, 14]. Even in nations where opioids are more readily available and accepted, some prescribers may hesitate to utilize them, even when they are medically appropriate, for fear of fueling opioid misuse and abuse or concern about legal liability [15].…”
Since 1986, the pharmacological management of pain was mainly based on the WHO âanalgesic ladderâ, with very few drugs available. The huge development of the basic knowledge on pain and its therapy, especially in the past 15Â years, has made the âguidelinesâ of WHO obsolete. Thatâs why, during the presidency of EFIC of one of the authors (GV), an international advisory board was proposed to review the document, but mainly to ameliorate the approach to the pain patients.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citationsâcitations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.