“…Unfortunately, the mechanisms by which GR SO 4 forms during the various procedures are poorly understood; it not clear if precursors are required for GR SO 4 formation, or if the phase can precipitate directly from solution. Neither has the role of potential precursors been thoroughly established, although it has been suggested that electron transfer from adsorbed Fe II to precursor goethite leads to brucitelike Fe II /Fe III hydroxide layers (Ahmed et al, 2010). Thus, we cannot unambiguously state that GR SO 4 formation mechanisms differ for the various synthesis methods, but should this be the case, variation in structure, composition and charge of the first formed green rust-like solid could affect the degree of Na + incorporation.…”