Form and Context: An Essay in the History of Narratology

Abstract

This essay compares two distinct traditions of narrative theory: on the one hand, that of structuralist narratology as it emerged in the 1960s and in its various subsequent manifestations; on the other, that of German-languageErzähltheorie as codified in the 1950s, with a prehistory dating back to German classicism. Having mapped the connections between these traditions, this essay then concentrates on exploring how narratology, unlike German narrative theory, has come to broaden its project exponentially since its first critical incarnation as a strictly formalist poetics. While the German tradition has concentrated on rhetoric and voice (with reception theory constituting a largely separate area of inquiry), narratology, which frames the text within a symmetry of real, implied, and fictional intelligences, has always had the potential to pose questions about how narrative functions in relation to a surrounding world of ideas. Of the two only narratology can therefore theorize both authorship and reading. In specific terms, this essay argues that the controversial narratological abstraction of implied authorship represents the only point at which a negotiation between textual and contextual worlds can logically take place. Evidence of how crucial such theorization has been in the development of contextualist narratology is sought in the examination of a test case, namely the much-disputed project of feminist narratology.

Exploring Interpretation of Complexity and Typicality in Narratives and Statistical Images about the Social Determinants of Health

“…In this article we employ the narrative definition constructed by Kreuter and colleagues: "a representation of connected events and characters that has an identifiable structure, is bounded in space and time, and contains implicit or explicit messages about the topic being addressed" (Kreuter et al 2007, p. 222), which draws on the long history of research on the form and function of narrative (for an overview and discussion, see Darby, 2001). We also use the terms "narrative" and "story" interchangeably.…”

The Narrative Turn and the Poetics of Resistance: Towards a New Language for Critical Educational Studies

“…Darby (2001) himself talks of 'a tale of two formalisms' mentioning a German tradition initiated by the work of Eberhard Lämmert and Franz Stanzel (1984) dating from 1955 and issuing in a series of important texts. Also a more nuanced understanding of contemporary lines of development would recognize not only the Russian formalists but also the work of Georg Lukács (1885Lukács ( -1975 on the novel who adopted Marxist categories under the inspiration of Hegel (and under the spell of Dilthey, Simmel and Weber) to problematize the naturalism of the European novel and outline the historicization of aesthetic forms (see Lukács, 1962).…”

The Family and Business Life of Harriet Hubbard Ayer, Culminating in Fights over Her Person and Property

“…Letters sent from one person to another were private expressions. 68 Ayer first presented this backstory for public consumption in an advertisement written as a news item headed "Successful Women." 62 Safety, reliability, and gender identification fused together.…”