Forecasting volatility during the outbreak of Russian invasion of Ukraine: application to commodities, stock indices, currencies, and cryptocurrencies

Abstract

Research background: The Russian invasion on Ukraine of February 24, 2022 sharply raised the volatility in commodity and financial markets. This had the adverse effect on the accuracy of volatility forecasts. The scale of negative effects of war was, however, market-specific and some markets exhibited a strong tendency to return to usual levels in a short time. Purpose of the article: We study the volatility shocks caused by the war. Our focus is on the markets highly exposed to the effects of this conflict: the stock, currency, cryptocurrency, gold, wheat and crude oil markets. We evaluate the forecasting accuracy of volatility models during the first stage of the war and compare the scale of forecast deterioration among the examined markets. Our long-term purpose is to analyze the methods that have the potential to mitigate the effect of forecast deterioration under such circumstances. We concentrate on the methods designed to deal with outliers and periods of extreme volatility, but, so far, have not been investigated empirically under the conditions of war. Methods: We use the robust methods of estimation and a modified Range-GARCH model which is based on opening, low, high and closing prices. We compare them with the standard maximum likelihood method of the classic GARCH model. Moreover, we employ the MCS (Model Confidence Set) procedure to create the set of superior models. Findings & value added: Analyzing the market specificity, we identify both some common patterns and substantial differences among the markets, which is the first comparison of this type relating to the ongoing conflict. In particular, we discover the individual nature of the cryptocurrency markets, where the reaction to the outbreak of the war was very limited and the accuracy of forecasts remained at the similar level before and after the beginning of the war. Our long-term contribution are the findings about suitability of methods that have the potential to handle the extreme volatility but have not been examined empirically under the conditions of war. We reveal that the Range-GARCH model compares favorably with the standard volatility models, even when the latter are evaluated in a robust way. It gives valuable implication for the future research connected with military conflicts, showing that in such period gains from using more market information outweigh the benefits of using robust estimators.

Impact of the Russo-Ukrainian war on Black Sea trade: Geoeconomic challenges

“…At the same time, recent history has shown us that asymmetrical economic interdependencies do not promote stability but create vulnerabilities (Keohane & Nye, 1973;Cu and Nguyen, 2022). This dependence on essential resources makes specific markets vulnerable to political pressure or economic manipulation (Fiszeder & Małecka, 2022;Kozmenko, & Ostapenko, 2022;Kustina et al, 2023;Kozmenko et al, 2023). This type of asymmetric relationship determined the energy decoupling of European states from Russia after the start of the second stage of the Russia-Ukraine War on February 24, 2022, in their desire to avoid political blackmail.…”

Determination of iron procurement strategy for manufacturing companies

“…iron price fluctuations (Lv et al, 2022;Kolková, & Ključnikov, 2021;Kolkova & Rozehnal, 2022). A time series includes statistical data on various quantitative indicators of economic and social phenomena in a time sequence, and methods based on time series analysis comprise various estimation techniques (Landmesser, 2021;Fiszeder & Małecka, 2022), where the most important technique is the exponential smoothing estimation method (Kahraman & Akay, 2022). Ten years time series analysis was used by Jeremić et al (2022) in their research on agricultural development in Serbia, examining the relationship between crude oil and gold and the price of iron, concluding that changes in the price of steel cause a gradual increase in the price of agricultural machinery, which significantly increases the cost of agricultural production.…”

Alternative investments during turbulent times comparison of dynamic relationship

“…The same happened to European currencies, which depreciated against the US dollar. The prices of Russia-or Ukraine-produced commodities like crude oil, natural gas or wheat rose very fast (Fiszeder & Małecka, 2022).…”