Highlights
We merge two unique historical datasets on commodity and stock prices covering four centuries and three leading stock markets (Netherlands, UK, and US).
Consistent with theoretical predictions, commodity returns can predict stock returns.
Specifically, 64% and 56% of the commodity returns can predict stock returns in-sample and out-of-sample, respectively.
Commodity returns from agriculture, energy, and livestock and meat markets consistently predict stock returns.
These results are robust to recessions and expansions.