Forecasting intensive care unit demand during the COVID-19 pandemic: A spatial age-structured microsimulation model

Abstract

BackgroundThe COVID-19 pandemic poses the risk of overburdening health care systems, and in particular intensive care units (ICUs). Non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs), ranging from wearing masks to (partial) lockdowns have been implemented as mitigation measures around the globe. However, especially severe NPIs are used with great caution due to their negative effects on the economy, social life and mental well-being. Thus, understanding the impact of the pandemic on ICU demand under alternative scenarios reflecting different levels of NPIs is vital for political decision-making on NPIs.ObjectiveThe aim is to support political decision-making by forecasting COVID-19-related ICU demand under alternative scenarios of COVID-19 progression reflecting different levels of NPIs. Substantial sub-national variation in COVID-19-related ICU demand requires a spatially disaggregated approach. This should not only take sub-national variation in ICU-relevant disease dynamics into account, but also variation in the population at risk including COVID-19-relevant risk characteristics (e.g. age), and factors mitigating the pandemic. The forecast provides indications for policy makers and health care stakeholders as to whether mitigation measures have to be maintained or even strengthened to prevent ICU demand from exceeding supply, or whether there is leeway to relax them.MethodsWe implement a spatial age-structured microsimulation model of the COVID-19 pandemic by extending the Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered (SEIR) framework. The model accounts for regional variation in population age structure and in spatial diffusion pathways. In a first step, we calibrate the model by applying a genetic optimization algorithm against hospital data on ICU patients with COVID-19. In a second step, we forecast COVID-19-related ICU demand under alternative scenarios of COVID 19 progression reflecting different levels of NPIs. We apply the model to Germany and provide state-level forecasts over a 2-month period, which can be updated daily based on latest data on the progression of the pandemic.ResultsTo illustrate the merits of our model, we present here “forecasts” of ICU demand for different stages of the pandemic during 2020. Our forecasts for a quiet summer phase with low infection rates identified quite some variation in potential for relaxing NPIs across the federal states. By contrast, our forecasts during a phase of quickly rising infection numbers in autumn (second wave) suggested that all federal states should implement additional NPIs. However, the identified needs for additional NPIs varied again across federal states. In addition, our model suggests that during large infection waves ICU demand would quickly exceed supply, if there were no NPIs in place to contain the virus.ConclusionOur results provide evidence for substantial spatial variation in (1) the effect of the pandemic on ICU demand, and (2) the potential and need for NPI adjustments at different stages of the pandemic. Forecasts with our spatial age-structured microsimulation model allow to take this spatial variation into account. The model is programmed in R and can be applied to other countries, provided that reliable data on the number of ICU patients infected with COVID-19 are available at sub-national level.

International travel in times of the COVID-19 pandemic: The case of German school breaks

“…A.2 , mobility increased predominantly in states and counties in the north and east of Germany where the COVID-19 incidence remained at an extremely low level throughout the summer months. This explanation is consistent with the modeling results by Klüsener et al (2020) that there was room for further relaxing NPIs in Germany during the summer months due to the weak dynamics of the pandemic in this period.…”

Variation in mortality burden of the COVID-19 pandemic across federal states in Germany

“…A higher ICU occupancy rate by COVID-19 patients was correlated with higher excess mortality, which indicates that ICU capacity and the preparedness of the health care system contributed substantially to the spatial variation in the burden of the COVID-19 pandemic. 31 , 32 While the cumulative numbers of confirmed COVID-19 cases had a significant effect on the excess mortality cumulated over the study period, a correlation between weekly confirmed COVID-19 cases and weekly excess mortality was not observed for the northern federal states of Bremen, Hamburg, Lower Saxony and Schleswig-Holstein. This result may be explained by the differences in the testing strategies of the federal states.…”

The impact of the COVID‐19 pandemic on internal migration in Germany: A descriptive analysis

“…In addition, gatherings in public places were limited to members of two households. On December 16, the lockdown was extended to the nationwide closure of schools, childcare facilities, and nonessential shopping (Klüsener et al, 2020 ). The second lockdown continued to be in place until April 2021.…”