The second phase of the biphasic force decay upon release of phosphate from caged phosphate was previously interpreted as a signature of kinetics of the force-generating step in the cross-bridge cycle. To test this hypothesis without using caged compounds, force responses and individual sarcomere dynamics upon rapid increases or decreases in concentration of inorganic phosphate [P i ] were investigated in calcium-activated cardiac myofibrils. Rapid increases in [P i ] induced a biphasic force decay with an initial slow decline (phase 1) and a subsequent 3-5-fold faster major decay (phase 2). Phase 2 started with the distinct elongation of a single sarcomere, the so-called sarcomere ''give''. ''Give'' then propagated from sarcomere to sarcomere along the myofibril. Propagation speed and rate constant of phase 2 (k þPi(2) ) had a similar [P i ]-dependence, indicating that the kinetics of the major force decay (phase 2) upon rapid increase in [P i ] is determined by sarcomere dynamics. In contrast, no ''give'' was observed during phase 1 after rapid [P i ]-increase (rate constant k þPi (1) ) and during the single-exponential force rise (rate constant k ÀPi ) after rapid [P i ]-decrease. The values of k þPi(1) and k ÀPi were similar to the rate constant of mechanically induced force redevelopment (k TR ) and Ca 2þ -induced force development (k ACT ) measured at same [P i ]. These results indicate that the major phase 2 of force decay upon a P i -jump does not reflect kinetics of the force-generating step but results from sarcomere ''give''. The other phases of P i -induced force kinetics that occur in the absence of ''give'' yield the same information as mechanically and Ca 2þ -induced force kinetics (k þPi(1)~k-Pi~kTR~kACT ). Model simulations indicate that P i -induced force kinetics neither enable the separation of P i -release from the rate-limiting transition f into force states nor differentiate whether the ''forcegenerating step'' occurs before, along, or after the P i -release.